Porphyria cutanea tarda and hepatitis C virus: A case-control study and meta-analysis of the literature

Background: Porphyria cutanea tarda (PCT) and hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection have been associated in several reports with the prevalence of HCV exhibiting considerable regional variation. However, most reports were confounded by selection bias and a regional prevalence of HCV in the populations studied. In the United States, only a few cases of this association have been reported to date. Objective: We conducted a study to evaluate the association between PCT and HCV in a US population. We used a case-control study design to control the systemic error that may occur during a selecting process or sampling procedure. Methods: We reviewed the medical records of Wishard Memorial Hospital, a county hospital serving metropolitan Indianapolis, Indiana, to perform a retrospective case-control study of 26 patients with PCT (as case) against 149,756 regional volunteer blood donors (as control-1) and 51 patients receiving methotrexate for psoriasis (as control-2). HCV antibody titers and other liver abnormalities were our main outcome measures. We then performed a weighted meta-analysis of 17 reports that had at least 17 patients in their study populations. Results: Sixteen (94%) of 17 PCT patients tested for HCV were antibody positive. Among blood donors, only 255 or 0.17% were HCV antibody positive (P < 10(-5), two-sided chi-square test). Of 5 psoriasis patients tested for HCV none were HCV antibody positive (P = .0002, two-sided Fisher's exact test). For geographic comparison, meta-analysis of the literature demonstrated a varying regional prevalence of HCV in PCT patients as follows: Northern Europe 17%, Australia/New Zealand 20%, and Southern Europe 65%. Conclusion: Although a marked geographic variation was found in the worldwide prevalence of HCV in PCT patients, a very large percentage of US patients with PCT had HCV infection. Our results emphasize the need for clinicians to actively look for HCV in patients with PCT.