Basic principles for evaluating an earthquake prediction method

被引:61
作者
Varotsos, P [1 ]
Eftaxias, K [1 ]
Vallianatos, F [1 ]
Lazaridou, M [1 ]
机构
[1] TECH UNIV CRETA, KHANIA, GREECE
关键词
D O I
10.1029/96GL00905
中图分类号
P [天文学、地球科学];
学科分类号
07 ;
摘要
A three year continuous sample of earthquake predictions based on the observation of Seismic Electric Signals in Greece was published by Varotsos and Lazaridou [1991]. Four independent studies analyzed this sample and concluded that the success rate of the predictions is far beyond chance. On the other hand, Mulargia and Gasperini [1992] (hereafter cited as MG) claim that these predictions can be ascribed to chance. In the present paper we examine the origin of this disagreement. Several serious problems in the study of MG are pointed out, such as: 1. The probability of a prediction's being successful by chance should be approximately considered as the product of three probabilities, P-T, P-E and P-M, i.e., the probabilities with respect to time, epicenter and magnitude. In spite of their major importance, P-E and P-M were ignored by MG. The incorporation of P-E decreases the probability for chancy success by more than a factor of 10 (when P-E is taken into account it can be shown that the VAN predictions cannot be ascribed to chance). 2. MG grossly overestimated the number of earthquakes that should have been predicted, by taking different thresholds for earthquakes and predictions. With such an overestimation, MG's procedure can ''reject'' even an ideally perfect earthquake prediction method. 3. MG's procedure did not take into account that the predictions were based on three different types of electrical precursors with different lead-times. 4. MG applied a Poisson distribution to the time series of earthquakes but included a large number of aftershocks. 5. The backward time correlation between predictions and earthquakes claimed by MG is due to misinterpretation of the text of some predictions and an incorrect use of aftershocks. Although even the discussion of the first problem alone is enough to invalidate the claims of MG, we also discuss the other four problems because MG violated some basic principles even in the time domain alone. The results derived in this paper are of general use when examining whether a correlation between earthquakes and various geophysical phenomena is beyond chance or not.
引用
收藏
页码:1295 / 1298
页数:4
相关论文
共 18 条
[1]   A 3 YEAR CONTINUOUS SAMPLE OF OFFICIALLY DOCUMENTED PREDICTIONS ISSUED IN GREECE USING THE VAN METHOD - 1987-1989 [J].
DOLOGLOU, E .
TECTONOPHYSICS, 1993, 224 (1-3) :189-202
[2]   ON THE ORIGIN OF ELECTROTELLURIC DISTURBANCES PRIOR TO AN EARTHQUAKE IN KALAMATA, GREECE [J].
GERSHENZON, N ;
GOKHBERG, M .
TECTONOPHYSICS, 1993, 224 (1-3) :169-174
[3]   STATISTICAL EVALUATION OF THE SES PREDICTIONS ISSUED IN GREECE - ALARM AND SUCCESS RATES [J].
HAMADA, K .
TECTONOPHYSICS, 1993, 224 (1-3) :203-210
[4]   NOTE ON A POSSIBLE ORIGIN FOR SEISMIC ELECTRICAL SIGNALS [J].
LAZARUS, D .
TECTONOPHYSICS, 1993, 224 (1-3) :265-267
[5]   EVALUATING THE STATISTICAL VALIDITY BEYOND CHANCE OF VAN EARTHQUAKE PRECURSORS [J].
MULARGIA, F ;
GASPERINI, P .
GEOPHYSICAL JOURNAL INTERNATIONAL, 1992, 111 (01) :32-44
[6]  
Nishizawa O, 1994, ELECTROMAGNETIC PHEN, P459
[7]   ELECTROMAGNETIC PRECURSORS TO EARTHQUAKES IN THE ULF BAND - A REVIEW OF OBSERVATIONS AND MECHANISMS [J].
PARK, SK ;
JOHNSTON, MJS ;
MADDEN, TR ;
MORGAN, FD ;
MORRISON, HF .
REVIEWS OF GEOPHYSICS, 1993, 31 (02) :117-132
[8]   STATISTICAL EVALUATION OF THE VAN PREDICTIONS ISSUED DURING THE PERIOD 1987-1989 [J].
SHNIRMAN, M ;
SCHREIDER, S ;
DMITRIEVA, O .
TECTONOPHYSICS, 1993, 224 (1-3) :211-221
[9]   SEISMIC ELECTRIC SIGNALS FROM DISPLACEMENT OF CHARGED DISLOCATIONS [J].
SLIFKIN, L .
TECTONOPHYSICS, 1993, 224 (1-3) :149-152
[10]   EVALUATING THE STATISTICAL VALIDITY BEYOND CHANCE OF VAN EARTHQUAKE PRECURSORS - COMMENT [J].
TAKAYAMA, H .
GEOPHYSICAL JOURNAL INTERNATIONAL, 1993, 115 (03) :1197-1198