On T cells the leukocyte integrin leukocyte function-associated antigen-1 (LFA-1) (CD11a/CD18) can be induced to bind its ligand intercellular adhesion molecule 1 (ICAM-1) (CD54) either by increasing the affinity of the receptor with Mg2+ and EGTA or by receptor clustering following activation with phorbol ester, The existence of these two adhesion-inducing pathways implies that alternative mechanisms might exist by which LFA-1 engages ICAM-1. The LFA-1 alpha subunit I domain contains a major binding site for ICAM-1. In this study me show that soluble LFA-1 I domain blocks ICAM-1 binding of the high affinity Mg2+-induced form of LFA-1 but not the phorbol ester-induced form. Under conditions of Mg2+-activation, the soluble I domain also prevents expression of an activation dependent epitope on LFA-1, implying that it inhibits a conformational change necessary for conversion to the high affinity form of this integrin. In addition, the binding of Mg2+-activated LFA-1 to ICAM-1 is blocked by peptides covering the alpha 4-beta 3 loop, the beta 3-alpha 5 loop, and the alpha 5 helix of the I domain, whereas none of the peptides tested blocks phorbol ester-mediated adhesion. The blocking peptides localize to the same face of the crystal structure of the LFA-1 I domain and define an area that, during activation, may be involved in association of the I domain with another region of LFA-1, potentially the beta-propeller domain. This is the first evidence Linking a structural domain of an integrin, in this case the I domain, with a particular activation mechanism.