Methods for comparing the yield stability of cropping systems - A review

被引:212
作者
Piepho, HP [1 ]
机构
[1] Inst Nutzpflanzenkunde, D-37231 Witzenhausen, Germany
关键词
stability; genotype-by-environment interaction; system-by-environment interaction; variance components; intercropping; cultivar mixtures; multilines; cropping system; agronomic practices; mixed model;
D O I
10.1111/j.1439-037X.1998.tb00526.x
中图分类号
S3 [农学(农艺学)];
学科分类号
0901 ;
摘要
The stability of yield is an important characteristic to be considered when judging the value of a cropping system relative to others. In the context of agricultural research, the analysis of yield stability has been largely confined to multienvironment trials of crop cultivars. This review emphasizes that methods for comparing the stability of cultivars can also be used for comparing different agronomic treatments in general, of which cultivars are but a special case. Throughout the paper, different agronomic treatments are referred to as cropping systems. Some of the methods useful for stability analysis of cropping systems are discussed and a brief review of applications of these methods is given. The paper puts different stability measures into a unifying mixed model perspective.
引用
收藏
页码:193 / 213
页数:21
相关论文
共 137 条
[31]   YIELDING ABILITY AND YIELD STABILITY OF LINSEED IN CENTRAL-EUROPE [J].
DIEPENBROCK, WA ;
LEON, J ;
CLASEN, K .
AGRONOMY JOURNAL, 1995, 87 (01) :84-88
[32]   MODIFIED JOINT REGRESSION-ANALYSIS FOR INCOMPLETE VARIETY X ENVIRONMENT DATA [J].
DIGBY, PGN .
JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURAL SCIENCE, 1979, 93 (AUG) :81-86
[33]  
Dornescu D., 1995, Analele Institutului de Cercetari pentru Cereale si Plante Tehnice, Fundulea, V62, P139
[34]  
Dornescu D., 1994, Cercetari Agronomice in Moldova, V27, P71
[35]   SENSITIVITY (STABILITY) ANALYSIS OF MULTIPLE VARIETY TRIALS, WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO DATA EXPRESSED AS PROPORTIONS OR PERCENTAGES [J].
DYKE, GV ;
LANE, PW ;
JENKYN, JF .
EXPERIMENTAL AGRICULTURE, 1995, 31 (01) :75-87
[36]   STABILITY PARAMETERS FOR COMPARING VARIETIES [J].
EBERHART, SA ;
RUSSELL, WA .
CROP SCIENCE, 1966, 6 (01) :36-&
[37]  
Eskridge K. M., 1996, P273
[38]   SELECTION OF STABLE CULTIVARS USING A SAFETY-1ST RULE [J].
ESKRIDGE, KM .
CROP SCIENCE, 1990, 30 (02) :369-374
[39]   CHOOSING PLANT CULTIVARS BASED ON THE PROBABILITY OF OUTPERFORMING A CHECK [J].
ESKRIDGE, KM ;
MUMM, RF .
THEORETICAL AND APPLIED GENETICS, 1992, 84 (3-4) :494-500
[40]   YIELD STABILITY IN INTERCROPPING STUDIES OF SORGHUM OR MAIZE WITH COWPEA OR COMMON BEAN UNDER DIFFERENT FERTILITY LEVELS IN NORTHEASTERN BRAZIL [J].
FARIS, MA ;
DEARAUJO, MRA ;
LIRA, MD ;
ARCOVERE, ASS .
CANADIAN JOURNAL OF PLANT SCIENCE, 1983, 63 (04) :789-799