Cloning differentially expressed mRNAs

被引:129
作者
Wan, JS [1 ]
Sharp, SJ [1 ]
Poirier, GMC [1 ]
Wagaman, PC [1 ]
Chambers, J [1 ]
Pyati, J [1 ]
Hom, YL [1 ]
Galindo, JE [1 ]
Huvar, A [1 ]
Peterson, PA [1 ]
Jackson, MR [1 ]
Erlander, MG [1 ]
机构
[1] RW JOHNSON PHARMACEUT RES INST,SAN DIEGO,CA 92121
关键词
differential display; subtractive hybridization; electronic subtraction; differential gene expression; EST;
D O I
10.1038/nbt1296-1685
中图分类号
Q81 [生物工程学(生物技术)]; Q93 [微生物学];
学科分类号
071005 ; 0836 ; 090102 ; 100705 ;
摘要
Differential gene expression occurs in the process of development, maintenance, injury, and death of unicellular as well as complex organisms. Differentially expressed genes are usually identified by comparing steady-state mRNA concentrations. Electronic subtraction (ES), subtractive hybridization (SH), and differential display (DD) are methods commonly used for this purpose. A rigorous examination has been lacking and therefore quantitative aspects of these methods remain speculative. We compare these methods by identifying a total of 58 unique differentially expressed mRNAs within the same experimental system (HeLa cells treated with interferon-gamma), ES yields digital, reusable data that quantitated steady-state mRNA concentrations but only identified abundant mRNAs (seven were identified), which represent a small fraction of the total number of differentially expressed mRNAs. SH and DD identified abundant and rare mRNAs (33 and 23 unique mRNAs respectively) with redundancy. The redundancy is mRNA abundance-dependent for SH and primer-dependent for DD. We conclude that DD is the method of choice because it identifies mRNAs independent of prevalence, uses small amounts of RNA, identifies increases and decreases of mRNA steady-state levels simultaneously, and has rapid output.
引用
收藏
页码:1685 / 1691
页数:7
相关论文
共 61 条
[1]   RAPID CDNA SEQUENCING (EXPRESSED SEQUENCE TAGS) FROM A DIRECTIONALLY CLONED HUMAN INFANT BRAIN CDNA LIBRARY [J].
ADAMS, MD ;
SOARES, MB ;
KERLAVAGE, AR ;
FIELDS, C ;
VENTER, JC .
NATURE GENETICS, 1993, 4 (04) :373-386
[2]   SEQUENCE IDENTIFICATION OF 2,375 HUMAN BRAIN GENES [J].
ADAMS, MD ;
DUBNICK, M ;
KERLAVAGE, AR ;
MORENO, R ;
KELLEY, JM ;
UTTERBACK, TR ;
NAGLE, JW ;
FIELDS, C ;
VENTER, JC .
NATURE, 1992, 355 (6361) :632-634
[3]  
ADAMS MD, 1995, NATURE, V377, P3
[4]  
ADAMS MD, 1993, NAT GENET, V4, P26
[5]   IDENTIFICATION OF MULTIPLE GENES IN BOVINE RETINAL PERICYTES ALTERED BY EXPOSURE TO ELEVATED LEVELS OF GLUCOSE BY USING MESSENGER-RNA DIFFERENTIAL DISPLAY [J].
AIELLO, LP ;
ROBINSON, GS ;
LIN, YW ;
NISHIO, Y ;
KING, GL .
PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, 1994, 91 (13) :6231-6235
[6]  
ALTSCHUL SF, 1990, J MOL BIOL, V215, P403, DOI 10.1006/jmbi.1990.9999
[7]   ANALYSIS OF COMPLEXITY AND DIVERSITY OF MESSENGER-RNA FROM CHICKEN LIVER AND OVIDUCT [J].
AXEL, R ;
FEIGELSON, P ;
SCHUTZ, G .
CELL, 1976, 7 (02) :247-254
[8]   IDENTIFICATION OF DIFFERENTIALLY EXPRESSED MESSENGER-RNA SPECIES BY AN IMPROVED DISPLAY TECHNIQUE (DDRT-PCR) [J].
BAUER, D ;
MULLER, H ;
REICH, J ;
RIEDEL, H ;
AHRENKIEL, V ;
WARTHOE, P ;
STRAUSS, M .
NUCLEIC ACIDS RESEARCH, 1993, 21 (18) :4272-4280
[9]   AN ANALYSIS OF DIFFERENTIAL DISPLAY SHOWS A STRONG BIAS TOWARDS HIGH COPY NUMBER MESSENGER-RNAS [J].
BERTIOLI, DJ ;
SCHLICHTER, UHA ;
ADAMS, MJ ;
BURROWS, PR ;
STEINBISS, HH ;
ANTONIW, JF .
NUCLEIC ACIDS RESEARCH, 1995, 23 (21) :4520-4523
[10]   3 ABUNDANCE CLASSES IN HELA-CELL MESSENGER-RNA [J].
BISHOP, JO ;
MORTON, JG ;
ROSBASH, M ;
RICHARDSON, M .
NATURE, 1974, 250 (5463) :199-204