The SCARE 2018 statement: Updating consensus Surgical CAse REport (SCARE) guidelines

被引：4578

作者：

Agha, Riaz A. ^{[1
]}

Borrelli, Mimi R. ^{[2
]}

Farwana, Reem ^{[3
]}

Koshy, Kiron ^{[4
]}

Fowler, Alexander J. ^{[5
]}

Orgill, Dennis P. ^{[6
,7
]}

Zhu, Hongyi ^{[8
]}

Alsawadi, Abdulrahman ^{[9
]}

Noureldin, Ashraf ^{[10
]}

Rao, Ashwini ^{[11
]}

Enam, Ather ^{[12
]}

Thoma, Achilleas ^{[13
]}

Bashashati, Mohammad ^{[14
]}

Vasudevan, Baskaran ^{[15
]}

Beamish, Andrew ^{[16
]}

Challacombe, Ben ^{[17
]}

De Wilde, Rudy Leon ^{[18
]}

Machado-Aranda, David ^{[19
]}

Laskin, Daniel ^{[20
]}

Muzumdar, Dattatraya ^{[21
]}

D'cruz, Anil ^{[22
]}

Manning, Todd ^{[23
]}

Healy, Donagh ^{[24
]}

Pagano, Duilio ^{[25
]}

Goel, Prabudh ^{[26
]}

Ranganathan, Priya ^{[27
]}

Pai, Prathamesh S. ^{[27
]}

Raja, Shahzad ^{[28
]}

Athe, M. Hammad ^{[12
]}

Kadioazlu, Huseyin ^{[29
]}

Nixon, Iain ^{[30
]}

Mukherjee, Indraneil ^{[31
]}

Gomez Riva, Juan ^{[32
]}

Raveendran, Kandiah ^{[33
]}

Derbyshire, Laura ^{[34
]}

Valmasoni, Michele ^{[35
]}

Chalkoo, Mushtaq ^{[33
]}

Raison, Nicholas ^{[36
]}

Muensterer, Oliver ^{[37
]}

Bradley, Patrick ^{[38
]}

Roberto, Coppola ^{[39
]}

Afifi, Raafat ^{[40
]}

Rosin, David ^{[41
]}

Klappenbach, Roberto ^{[42
]}

Wynn, Rolf ^{[43
]}

Giordano, Salvatore ^{[44
]}

Basu, Somprakas ^{[45
]}

Surani, Salim ^{[46
]}

Suman, Paritosh

Thorat, Mangesh ^{[47
]}

机构：

[1] Chelsea & Westminster Hosp NHS Fdn Trust, London, England

[2] Stanford Univ, Sch Med, Hagey Lab Pediat Regenerat Med, Dept Surg,Div Plast Surg, Stanford, CA 94305 USA

[3] Univ Birmingham, Med Sch, Birmingham, W Midlands, England

[4] Newcastle Tyne Hosp NHS Fdn Trust, Dept Plast Surg, Royal Victoria Infirm, Newcastle Upon Tyne, Tyne & Wear, England

[5] Royal London Hosp, Crit Care & Perioperat Med Res Grp, London, England

[6] Brigham & Womens Hosp, Div Plast Surg, Boston, MA 02115 USA

[7] Harvard Med Sch, Boston, MA 02115 USA

[8] Univ Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721 USA

[9] Colchester Hosp Univ NHS Fdn Trust, Colchester, Essex, England

[10] Cumberland Royal Infirm, Carlisle, England

[11] Saad Specialist Hosp, Khobar, Saudi Arabia

[12] Aga Khan Univ, Karachi, Pakistan

[13] McMaster Univ, Hamilton, ON, Canada

[14] Texas Tech Univ, Hlth Sci Ctr, Lubbock, TX 79409 USA

[15] MIOT Hosp, Madras, Tamil Nadu, India

[16] Univ Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden

[17] Guys Hosp, London, England

[18] Pius Hosp Oldenburg, Oldenburg, Germany

[19] Univ Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA

[20] Virginia Commonwealth Univ, Richmond, VA 23284 USA

[21] King Edward Mem Hosp, Bombay, Maharashtra, India

[22] Tata Mem Hosp, Bombay, Maharashtra, India

[23] Austin Hlth, Pune, Maharashtra, India

[24] Univ Hosp Waterford, Waterford, Ireland

[25] ISMETT UPMC, Palermo, Italy

[26] All India Inst Med Sci, New Delhi, India

[27] Tata Mem Hosp, Bombay, Maharashtra, India

[28] Royal Brompton & Harefield NHS Fdn Trust, London, England

[29] Bezmialem Vakif Univ, Istanbul, Turkey

[30] East Kent Univ Hosp, Canterbury, Kent, England

[31] Staten Isl Univ Hosp, Staten Isl, NY USA

[32] Hosp Univ La Paz, Madrid, Spain

[33] Fatimah Hosp, Ipoh, Malaysia

[34] NW Deanery, Manchester, Lancs, England

[35] Univ Padua, Padua, Italy

[36] Kings Coll London, London, England

[37] Univ Med Mainz, Mainz, Germany

[38] Nottingham Univ Hosp, Nottingham, England

[39] Campus Biomed Univ, Sch Med, Rome, Italy

[40] Cairo Univ, Cairo, Egypt

[41] Univ West Indies, Kingston, Jamaica

[42] Simplemente Evita Hosp, Gonzalez Catan, Buenos Aires, Argentina

[43] Univ Tromso, Tromso, Norway

[44] Turku Univ Hosp, Turku, Finland

[45] Banarus Hindu Univ, Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh, India

[46] Texas A&M Univ, College Stn, TX 77843 USA

[47] Queen Mary Univ London, Wolfson Inst Prevent Med, London, England

[48] UCL, London, England

来源：

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SURGERY | 2018年 / 60卷

关键词：

D O I：

10.1016/j.ijsu.2018.10.028

中图分类号：

R61 [外科手术学];

学科分类号：

100210 [外科学];

摘要：

Introduction: The SCARE Guidelines were published in 2016 to provide a structure for reporting surgical case reports. Since their publication, SCARE guidelines have been widely endorsed by authors, journal editors, and reviewers, and have helped to improve reporting transparency of case reports across a range of surgical specialties. In order to encourage further progress in reporting quality, the SCARE guidelines must themselves be kept up to date. We completed a Delphi consensus exercise to update the SCARE guidelines. Methods: A Delphi consensus exercise was undertaken. All members of the previous Delphi group were invited to participate, in addition to researchers who have previously studied case reports, and editors from the International Journal of Surgery Case Reports. The expert group was sent an online questionnaire where they were asked to rate their agreement with proposed changes to each of the 24 items. Results: 56 people agreed to participate and 45 (80%) invitees completed the survey which put forward modifications to the original guideline. The collated responses resulted in modifications. There was high agreement amongst the expert group. Conclusion: A modified and improved SCARE checklist is presented, after a Delphi consensus exercise was completed.

引用

页码：132 / 136

页数：5

共 8 条

[1]

Impact of the SCARE guideline on the reporting of surgical case reports: A before and after study [J].

Agha, R. A. ;

Farwana, R. ;

Borrelli, M. R. ;

Tickunas, T. ;

Kusu-Orkar, T. ;

Millip, M. C. ;

Thavayogan, R. ;

Garner, J. ;

Orgill, D. P. .

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 2017, 45 :144-148

[2]

Support for reporting guidelines in surgical journals needs improvement: A systematic review [J].

Agha, Riaz A. ;

Barai, Ishani ;

Rajmohan, Shivanchan ;

Lee, Seon ;

Anwar, Mohammed O. ;

Fowler, Alexander J. ;

Orgill, Dennis P. ;

Altman, Douglas G. .

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 2017, 45 :14-17

[3]

The SCARE Statement: Consensus-based surgical case report guidelines [J].

Agha, Riaz A. ;

Fowler, Alexander J. ;

Saeta, Alexandra ;

Barai, Ishani ;

Rajmohan, Shivanchan ;

Orgill, Dennis P. ;

Afifi, Raafat ;

Al-Ahmadi, Raha ;

Albrecht, Joerg ;

Alsawadi, Abdulrahman ;

Aronson, Jeffrey ;

Ather, M. Hammad ;

Bashashati, Mohammad ;

Basu, Somprakas ;

Bradley, Patrick ;

Chalkoo, Mushtaq ;

Challacombe, Ben ;

Cross, Trent ;

Derbyshire, Laura ;

Farooq, Naheed ;

Hoffman, Jerome ;

Kadioglu, Huseyin ;

Kasivisvanathan, Veeru ;

Kirshtein, Boris ;

Klappenbach, Roberto ;

Laskin, Daniel ;

Miguel, Diana ;

Milburn, James ;

Mousavi, Seyed Reza ;

Muensterer, Oliver ;

Ngu, James ;

Nixon, Iain ;

Noureldin, Ashraf ;

Perakath, Benjamin ;

Raison, Nicholas ;

Raveendran, Kandiah ;

Sullivan, Timothy ;

Thoma, Achilleas ;

Thorat, Mangesh ;

Valmasoni, Michele ;

Massarut, Samuele ;

D'cruz, Anil ;

Vasudevan, Baskaran ;

Giordano, Salvatore ;

Roy, Gaurav ;

Healy, Donagh ;

Machado-Aranda, David ;

Carroll, Bryan ;

Rosin, David .

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 2016, 34 :180-186

[4]

[Anonymous], 2001, Clinical case reporting in evidence-based medicine

[5]

Gopikrishna Velayutham, 2010, J Conserv Dent, V13, P265, DOI 10.4103/0972-0707.73375

[6]

DELPHI METHOD - SUBSTANCE, CONTEXT - CRITIQUE AN AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY [J].

PILL, J .

SOCIO-ECONOMIC PLANNING SCIENCES, 1971, 5 (01) :57-71

[7]

Instructions to authors for case reporting are limited: A review of a core journal list [J].

Olanrewaju Sorinola ;

Olufemi Olufowobi ;

Aravinthan Coomarasamy ;

Khalid S Khan .

BMC Medical Education, 4 (1)

[8]

Wright SM, 2000, CAN MED ASSOC J, V163, P429

← 1 →