Many surface proteins are anchored to the cell wall by the action of sortase enzymes, a recently discovered family of cysteine transpeptidases. As the surface proteins of human pathogens are frequently required for virulence, the sortase-mediated anchoring reaction represents a potential target for new anti-infective agents. It has been suggested that the sortase from Staphylococcus aureus (SrtA), may use a similar catalytic strategy as the papain cysteine proteases, holding its Cys(184) side chain in an active configuration through a thiolate-imidazolium ion interaction with residue His(120). To investigate the mechanism of transpeptidation, we have synthesized a peptidyl-vinyl sulfone substrate mimic that irreversibly inhibits SrtA. Through the study of the pH dependence of SrtA inhibition and NMR, we have estimated the pK(a)s of the active site thiol (Cys(184)) and imidazole (His(120)) to be similar to9.4 and 7.0, respectively. These measurements are inconsistent with the existence of a thiolate-imidazolium ion pair and suggest a general base catalysis mechanism during transpeptidation.