How to design and evaluate randomized controlled trials in immunotherapy for allergic rhinitis: an ARIA-GA2LEN statement

被引:77
作者
Bousquet, J. [1 ,2 ]
Schuenemann, H. J. [3 ]
Bousquet, P. J. [1 ]
Bachert, C. [4 ]
Canonica, G. W. [5 ]
Casale, T. B. [6 ]
Demoly, P. [1 ,7 ]
Durham, S.
Carlsen, K-H [8 ]
Malling, H-J [9 ]
Passalacqua, G. [5 ]
Simons, F. E. R. [10 ]
Anto, J. [11 ,12 ,13 ,14 ]
Baena-Cagnani, C. E. [15 ,16 ]
Bergmann, K-C [17 ]
Bieber, T. [18 ]
Briggs, A. H. [19 ]
Brozek, J. [3 ]
Calderon, M. A. [26 ,28 ]
Dahl, R. [20 ]
Devillier, P. [21 ]
van Wijk, R. Gerth [22 ]
Howarth, P. [27 ]
Larenas, D. [23 ]
Papadopoulos, N. G. [24 ]
Schmid-Grendelmeier, P. [25 ]
Zuberbier, T. [17 ]
机构
[1] Hop Arnaud de Villeneuve, Univ Hosp, F-34295 Montpellier 5, France
[2] CESP Ctr Res Epidemiol & Populat Hlth, INSERM, U1018, Resp & Environm Epidemiol Team, Villejuif, France
[3] McMaster Univ, Dept Clin Epidemiol & Biostat & Med, Hamilton, ON, Canada
[4] Ghent Univ Hosp, Upper Airways Res Lab URL, B-9000 Ghent, Belgium
[5] Univ Genoa, Dept Internal Med, DIMI, I-16126 Genoa, Italy
[6] Creighton Univ, Dept Med, Div Allergy & Immunol, Omaha, NE 68178 USA
[7] Hop Arnaud de Villeneuve, INSERM, U657, F-34295 Montpellier 5, France
[8] Univ Oslo, Rikshosp, Dept Paediat, Oslo Univ Hosp, N-0027 Oslo, Norway
[9] Natl Univ Hosp, Copenhagen, Denmark
[10] Univ Manitoba, Fac Med, Winnipeg, MB, Canada
[11] Ctr Res Environm Epidemiol CREAL, Barcelona, Spain
[12] Hosp del Mar, IMIM, Municipal Inst Med Res, Barcelona, Spain
[13] CIBERESP, Barcelona, Spain
[14] Univ Pompeu Fabra, Barcelona, Spain
[15] Catholic Univ, Fac Med, Cordoba, Argentina
[16] Univ Genoa, Sch Specializat, Genoa, Italy
[17] Charite, Dept Dermatol, Allergy Ctr Charite, D-13353 Berlin, Germany
[18] Univ Med Ctr, Dept Dermatol & Allergy, Bonn, Germany
[19] Univ Glasgow, Ctr Populat & Hlth Sci, Glasgow, Lanark, Scotland
[20] Aarhus Univ Hosp, Dept Resp Dis, DK-8000 Aarhus, Denmark
[21] Univ Versailles St Quentin, UPRES EA 220, Hop Foch, Suresnes, France
[22] Erasmus MC, Dept Internal Med, Sect Allergol, Rotterdam, Netherlands
[23] Hosp Med, Dept Allergy, Mexico City, DF, Mexico
[24] Univ Athens, Dept Allergy, Pediat Clin 2, Athens, Greece
[25] Univ Hosp, Dept Dermatol, Allergy Unit, Zurich, Switzerland
[26] Univ London Imperial Coll Sci Technol & Med, Natl Heart & Lung Inst, Sect Allergy & Clin Immunol, London, England
[27] Univ Southampton, Southampton, Hants, England
[28] Royal Brompton Hosp, London SW3 6LY, England
关键词
immunotherapy; randomized controlled trials; rhinitis; subcutaneous; sublingual; symptom score; QUALITY-OF-LIFE; FUROATE NASAL SPRAY; POLLEN INDUCED RHINOCONJUNCTIVITIS; SUBLINGUAL-SWALLOW IMMUNOTHERAPY; DOUBLE-BLIND; FLUTICASONE FUROATE; COST-EFFECTIVENESS; RESPIRATORY ALLERGY; CLINICAL-EFFICACY; HAY-FEVER;
D O I
10.1111/j.1398-9995.2011.02590.x
中图分类号
R392 [医学免疫学];
学科分类号
100102 ;
摘要
P>Specific immunotherapy (SIT) is one of the treatments for allergic rhinitis. However, for allergists, nonspecialists, regulators, payers, and patients, there remain gaps in understanding the evaluation of randomized controlled trials (RCTs). Although treating the same diseases, RCTs in SIT and pharmacotherapy should be considered separately for several reasons, as developed in this study. These include the severity and persistence of allergic rhinitis in the patients enrolled in the study, the problem of the placebo, allergen exposure (in particular pollen and mite), the analysis and reporting of the study, the level of symptoms of placebo-treated patients, the clinical relevance of the efficacy of SIT, the need for a validated combined symptom-medication score, the differences between children and adults and pharmacoeconomic analyses. This statement reviews issues raised by the interpretation of RCTs in sublingual immunotherapy. It is not possible to directly extrapolate the rules or parameters used in medication RCTs to SIT. It also provides some suggestions for the research that will be needed. Interestingly, some of the research questions can be approached with the available data obtained from large RCTs.
引用
收藏
页码:765 / 774
页数:10
相关论文
共 76 条
[1]   Injection allergen immunotherapy for asthma [J].
Abramson, Michael J. ;
Puy, Robert M. ;
Weiner, John M. .
COCHRANE DATABASE OF SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS, 2010, (08)
[2]   AIRBORNE RAGWEED ALLERGENS - ASSOCIATION WITH VARIOUS PARTICLE SIZES AND SHORT RAGWEED PLANT-PARTS [J].
AGARWAL, MK ;
SWANSON, MC ;
REED, CE ;
YUNGINGER, JW .
JOURNAL OF ALLERGY AND CLINICAL IMMUNOLOGY, 1984, 74 (05) :687-693
[3]  
[Anonymous], 2010, Drug Ther Bull, V48, P54, DOI 10.1136/dtb.2009.12.0062
[4]  
[Anonymous], 2008, CHMPEWP185042006
[5]   Grass pollen symptoms interfere with the recollection of birch pollen symptoms - a prospective study of suspected, asymptomatic skin sensitization [J].
Assing, K. ;
Bodtger, U. ;
Poulsen, L. K. ;
Malling, H. J. .
ALLERGY, 2007, 62 (04) :373-377
[6]   Cost-effectiveness of grass allergen tablet (GRAZAX®) for the prevention of seasonal grass pollen induced rhinoconjunctivitis -: a Northern European perspective [J].
Bachert, C. ;
Vestenbaek, U. ;
Christensen, J. ;
Griffiths, U. K. ;
Poulsen, P. B. .
CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL ALLERGY, 2007, 37 (05) :772-779
[7]   Prevalence, classification and perception of allergic and nonallergic rhinitis in Belgium [J].
Bachert, C ;
van Cauwenberge, P ;
Olbrecht, J ;
van Schoor, J .
ALLERGY, 2006, 61 (06) :693-698
[8]   Levocetirizine improves quality of life and reduces costs in long-term management of persistent allergic rhinitis [J].
Bachert, C ;
Bousquet, J ;
Canonica, GW ;
Durham, SR ;
Klimek, L ;
Mullol, J ;
Van Cauwenberge, PB ;
Van Hammée, G .
JOURNAL OF ALLERGY AND CLINICAL IMMUNOLOGY, 2004, 114 (04) :838-844
[9]   Recommendations for assessing Patient-Reported Outcomes and Health-Related quality of life in clinical trials on allergy: a GA2LEN taskforce position paper [J].
Baiardini, I. ;
Bousquet, P. J. ;
Brzoza, Z. ;
Canonica, G. W. ;
Compalati, E. ;
Fiocchi, A. ;
Fokkens, W. ;
van Wijk, R. G. ;
La Grutta, S. ;
Lombardi, C. ;
Maurer, M. ;
Pinto, A. M. ;
Ridolo, E. ;
Senna, G. E. ;
Terreehorst, I. ;
Bom, A. Todo ;
Bousquet, J. ;
Zuberbier, T. ;
Braido, F. .
ALLERGY, 2010, 65 (03) :290-295
[10]   Economic evaluation of sublingual immunotherapy vs symptomatic treatment in adults with pollen-induced respiratory allergy: the Sublingual Immunotherapy Pollen Allergy Italy (SPAI) study [J].
Berto, Patrizia ;
Passalacqua, Giovanni ;
Crimi, Nunzio ;
Frati, Franco ;
Ortolani, Claudio ;
Senna, Gianenrico ;
Canonica, Giorgio Walter .
ANNALS OF ALLERGY ASTHMA & IMMUNOLOGY, 2006, 97 (05) :615-621