ClC-1 chloride channel mutations in myotonia congenita: variable penetrance of mutations shifting the voltage dependence

Mutations in the CIC-1 muscle chloride channel cause either recessive or dominant myotonia congenita, Using a systematic screening procedure, we have now identified four novel missense mutations in dominant (V286A, F307S) and recessive myotonia (V236L, G285E), and have analysed the effect of these and other recently described mutations (A313T, I556N) on channel properties in the Xenopus oocyte expression system. Mutations V286A, F307S and A313T displayed a 'classical' dominant phenotype: their voltage dependence was shifted towards positive potentials and displayed a dominant-negative effect by significantly imparting a voltage shift on mutant-wild-type heteromeric channels as found in heterozygous patients. In contrast, the recessive mutation V236L also shifted the voltage dependence to positive values, but coexpression with wild-type CIC-1 gave almost wild-type currents. I556N, a mutation found in patients with benign dominant myotonia, drastically shifts the voltage dependence, but only a slight shift is seen when co-expressed with wild-type CIC-1, Thus, the voltage dependence of mutant heteromeric channels is not always intermediate between those of the constituent homomeric channel subunits, a conclusion further supported by mixing different CIC-1 mutants. These complex interactions correlate clinically with various inheritance patterns, ranging from autosomal dominant with various degrees of penetrance to autosomal recessive.