Does frontal normality exist in schizophrenia? A saccadic eye movement study

Many observations have supported the general idea of impaired frontal function in schizophrenia. In particular, neuropsychological studies have shown severe frontal deficits. However, other studies found normal cognitive function in a proportion of patients. Since saccadic tasks also provide an index of frontal function, we examined the presence of frontal deficits in patients by means of both neuropsychological and saccadic tasks, and compared the sensitivity of both approaches for frontal impairment. In addition, we examined the relationship between saccadic and neuropsychological measures. Twenty-four schizophrenic patients and twenty healthy controls completed an extensive neuropsychological battery and three saccadic tasks. Based on the neuropsychological battery alone, 42% of the patients showed frontal deficits, whereas combined use of neuropsychological and saccadic tasks resulted in 79% with frontal deficits. The antisaccade task appeared able to detect frontal deficits in patients who were without frontal impairment on the neuropsychological battery. Saccadic deficits were, however, not necessarily accompanied by deficits on frontal neuropsychological measures. This suggests that the saccadic and neuro psychological tasks used in the present study targeted different frontal functions. This view was supported by the lack of correlations between saccadic and frontal neuropsychological measures. (C) 2001 Elsevier Science Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.