You never call, you never write: why return of 'omic' results to research participants is both a good idea and a moral imperative

被引:30
作者
Angrist, Misha [1 ]
机构
[1] Duke Univ, Inst Genome Sci & Policy, Durham, NC 27708 USA
关键词
biobanking; genomic data; research ethics; return of results; GENETIC DISCRIMINATION; PSYCHOLOGICAL IMPACT; HEALTH-INSURANCE; INFORMATION; RISK; PERCEPTIONS; PROTECTIONS; DISCLOSURE; DISCOVERY; GENOMICS;
D O I
10.2217/PME.11.62
中图分类号
R9 [药学];
学科分类号
1007 ;
摘要
The rapid emergence of whole-genome and whole-exome sequencing of research participants has helped to revive the debate about whether genetic and other 'omic' data should be returned to research participants, and if so, which data, under what circumstances and by whom. While partial disclosure of such data has been justified in cases where participants' lives and health are threatened, full disclosure appears to remain beyond the pale for most researchers and bioethicists. I argue that it should not be and that the objections to full disclosure short-sightedly favor near-term considerations over long-term benefits. Return of genomic data to those who want it, even if a difficult undertaking and even if the meaning of the data is unclear, engages participants in science and the research enterprise, and positions them to be better stewards of their own health and wellbeing.
引用
收藏
页码:651 / 657
页数:7
相关论文
共 78 条
[51]  
Matutina Robin E, 2010, Nurse Res, V17, P83
[52]   A timely arrival for genomic medicine [J].
Mayer, Alan N. ;
Dimmock, David P. ;
Arca, Marjorie J. ;
Bick, David P. ;
Verbsky, James W. ;
Worthey, Elizabeth A. ;
Jacob, Howard J. ;
Margolis, David A. .
GENETICS IN MEDICINE, 2011, 13 (03) :195-196
[53]   An Unwelcome Side Effect of Direct-to-Consumer Personal Genome Testing Raiding the Medical Commons [J].
McGuire, Amy L. ;
Burke, Wylie .
JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 2008, 300 (22) :2669-2671
[54]   The Rule of Rescue [J].
McKie, J ;
Richardson, J .
SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE, 2003, 56 (12) :2407-2419
[55]   Toxic ignorance and right-to-know in biomonitoring results communication: a survey of scientists and study participants [J].
Morello-Frosch, Rachel ;
Brody, Julia Green ;
Brown, Phil ;
Altman, Rebecca Gasior ;
Rudel, Ruthann A. ;
Perez, Carla .
ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH, 2009, 8
[56]   The World of e-Patients: A Content Analysis of Online Social Networks Focusing on Diseases [J].
Orizio, Grazia ;
Schulz, Peter ;
Gasparotti, Cinzia ;
Caimi, Luigi ;
Gelatti, Umberto .
TELEMEDICINE JOURNAL AND E-HEALTH, 2010, 16 (10) :1060-1066
[57]  
Otlowski M, 2007, J LAW MED, V14, P367
[58]   Varietas: a functional variation database portal [J].
Paananen, Jussi ;
Ciszek, Robert ;
Wong, Garry .
DATABASE-THE JOURNAL OF BIOLOGICAL DATABASES AND CURATION, 2010, :baq016
[59]   The Characterization of Twenty Sequenced Human Genomes [J].
Pelak, Kimberly ;
Shianna, Kevin V. ;
Ge, Dongliang ;
Maia, Jessica M. ;
Zhu, Mingfu ;
Smith, Jason P. ;
Cirulli, Elizabeth T. ;
Fellay, Jacques ;
Dickson, Samuel P. ;
Gumbs, Curtis E. ;
Heinzen, Erin L. ;
Need, Anna C. ;
Ruzzo, Elizabeth K. ;
Singh, Abanish ;
Campbell, C. Ryan ;
Hong, Linda K. ;
Lornsen, Katharina A. ;
McKenzie, Alexander M. ;
Sobreira, Nara L. M. ;
Hoover-Fong, Julie E. ;
Milner, Joshua D. ;
Ottman, Ruth ;
Haynes, Barton F. ;
Goedert, James J. ;
Goldstein, David B. .
PLOS GENETICS, 2010, 6 (09)
[60]   Genetic discrimination in health insurance: Current legal protections and industry practices [J].
Pollitz, Karen ;
Peshkin, Beth N. ;
Bangit, Eliza ;
Lucia, Kevin .
INQUIRY-THE JOURNAL OF HEALTH CARE ORGANIZATION PROVISION AND FINANCING, 2007, 44 (03) :350-368