Acupuncture in headache: A critical review

被引:32
作者
Manias, P
Tagaris, G
Karageorgiou, K
机构
[1] Athens Headache & Chron Pain Ctr, Athens, Greece
[2] Athens Gen Hosp, Neurol Clin, Headache Ctr, Athens, Greece
关键词
D O I
10.1097/00002508-200012000-00010
中图分类号
R614 [麻醉学];
学科分类号
100217 ;
摘要
Twenty-seven clinical trials that evaluated the efficacy of acupuncture in the treatment of primary headaches (migraine headache, tension-type headache, and mixed forms) were reviewed. In the majority of the trials (23 of the 27 trials), it was concluded that acupuncture offers benefits in the treatment of headaches. Conversely, the evaluation of physical forms of treatment, including acupuncture, has special difficulties, and certain parameters in the study design need consideration. Acupuncture methods need individualization, a carefully selected placebo ("minimal acupuncture" seems to be best), and the crossover design must have adequate time between the two treatment periods. Clinical trials that evaluate acupuncture frequently are characterized by several inadequacies (including some from these evaluating headaches), but it seems that additional clinical research is necessary to confirm its efficacy and to clarify its indications.
引用
收藏
页码:334 / 339
页数:6
相关论文
共 72 条
[11]  
CARLSSON J, 1990, Pain Clinic, V3, P229
[12]   HEALTH-STATUS IN PATIENTS WITH TENSION HEADACHE TREATED WITH ACUPUNCTURE OR PHYSIOTHERAPY [J].
CARLSSON, J ;
AUGUSTINSSON, LE ;
BLOMSTRAND, C ;
SULLIVAN, M .
HEADACHE, 1990, 30 (09) :593-599
[13]  
CHAPMAN CR, 1991, ADV PAIN RES THERAPY, V18
[14]  
CHENG X, 1987, CHINESE ACUPUNCTURE, P2
[15]   ELECTROACUPUNCTURE AND POSTOPERATIVE PAIN [J].
CHRISTENSEN, PA ;
NORENG, M ;
ANDERSEN, PE ;
NIELSEN, JW .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF ANAESTHESIA, 1989, 62 (03) :258-262
[16]   DIFFUSE NOXIOUS INHIBITORY CONTROLS IN MAN - INVOLVEMENT OF THE SPINORETICULAR TRACT [J].
DEBROUCKER, T ;
CESARO, P ;
WILLER, JC ;
LEBARS, D .
BRAIN, 1990, 113 :1223-1234
[17]  
DOERRPROSKE H, 1985, Z PSYCHOSOM MED PSYC, V31, P247
[18]   THE EFFECTS OF ACUPUNCTURE VERSUS PLACEBO IN THE TREATMENT OF HEADACHE [J].
DOWSON, DI ;
LEWITH, GT ;
MACHIN, D .
PAIN, 1985, 21 (01) :35-42
[19]  
ERICTON J, 1995, ADV PAIN RES THERAPY, V21
[20]   HAS ACUPUNCTURE AN ANALGESIC EFFECT IN RABBIT [J].
GALEANO, C ;
LEUNG, CY .
PAIN, 1978, 4 (03) :265-271