Comparison of serological and DNA PCR-SSP typing results for HLA-A and HLA-B in 421 black individuals - A collaborative transplant study report

In a recent study, we observed a discrepancy race of 8.5% between the results of molecular and serological HLA class I typing in Caucasian kidney donors and recipients. In the present study we addressed the question how often black individuals are mistyped using the serological technique. 421 Blacks whose HLA typing results were reported to the Collaborative Transplant Study (CTS) were typed retrospectively for HLA-A and -B using a PCR-SSP method. 78 of the 421 individuals (18.5%) showed a discrepancy for HLA-A and 107 individuals (25.4%) for HLA-B. 36.3% of all individuals tested showed either an HLA-A or an HLA-B discrepancy. 13.1% of the discrepancies at the HLA-A locus were due to antigen misassignments and 4.8% were due to missed antigens. HLA-B discrepancies were caused in 15.7% by antigen misassignments and in 10.5% by missed antigens. These results demonstrate an impressive advantage of the PCR-SSP method for HLA-A and HLA-B locus typing over serological typing in black individuals. The high typing discrepancy rate observed in Blacks provides a strong argument for replacing serological typing by the DNA method. It is likely that this will improve the HLA matching correlation in clinical transplantation in Blacks. Human Immunology 59, 512-517 (1998). (C) American Society for Histocompatibility and Immunogenetics, 1998. Published by Elsevier Science Inc.