Soil phosphorus fractions after 111 years of animal manure and fertilizer applications

Accumulated soil P in agricultural soils is a major source of soluble and particulate forms of P entering water resources and degrading water quality. However, few research sites are currently available to evaluate the long-term effects of different cropping systems and fertility practices on soil inorganic and organic P accumulation. The objectives of this study were: (1) to compare the forms and quantity of different inorganic and organic soil P fractions in plots on Sanborn Field, which has been cultivated for 111 years; and (2) to assess the use of standard soil test P extractants for determining changes in soil P dynamics over time. A modified sequential P extraction procedure was used to separate labile and stable inorganic and organic P pools from surface soils collected on Sanborn Field in 1915, 1938, 1962, and 1999 from plots in continuous corn, continuous wheat, continuous timothy, and a corn-wheat-clover rotation amended with either manufactured fertilizers, horse or dairy manure or receiving no fertilization since 1888. Additional samples were collected from a native grass prairie site of a similar soil series to estimate soil characteristics at Sanborn Field before initial cultivation in 1888. Observed accumulation of Bray-1 P among fertilizer and manure treatments was attributed to over-application of P due to unrealistically high yield goals for each cropping system. Long-term cultivation of Sanborn Field increased soil bulk density and lowered soil pH and total organic C compared with native prairie. Fertilization either by addition of manufactured fertilizer or manure significantly increased inorganic resin-P and inorganic NaOH-extractable P. Applications of animal manure also significantly increased most organic P fractions compared with the unfertilized treatment. The native prairie had a larger proportion of total P in organic forms compared with cultivated plots, especially in organic NaOH-extractable P, but no significant decreases in either residual or total P were observed due to cultivation. This study confirms that soil P availability in cropping systems that are amended with predominantly organic P amendments may differ from conventional cropping systems relying on manufactured P fertilizers. However, no direct evidence was found to support the hypothesis that any individual inorganic or organic soil P fraction has a better relationship than conventional soil test P extractants with plant P uptake under contrasting organic and conventional fertility practices.