Evolutionary transitions of style polymorphisms in Lithodora (Boraginaceae)

Floral polymorphisms provide suitable model systems to test hypotheses concerning the evolution of outbreeding in plants. Although heterostyly has evolved in more than 28 angiosperm families, the evolutionary pathways involving related floral conditions have not yet been fully resolved. In this study, the reconstruction of ancestral states of style polymorphism, with both parsimony and maximum likelihood methods, was carried out for Boraginaceae species in the tribe Lithospermeae, particularly in the genus Lithodora sensu lato, where species present a wide variety of stylar conditions. Detailed floral morphometric analysis confirm different types of style polymorphism within Lithodora. They also reveal a novel style polymorphism (relaxed style dimorphism) in which anther height is variable within a flower (each anther being at a different height), which contrasts to regular distyly (constant anther height within flowers). Style monomorphism is likely to be the ancestral condition in Lithospermeae where the evolution of distyly has occurred several times. Style dimorphism is probably ancestral to distyly, as predicted by certain evolutionary models proposed for heterostyly. However, a reversion from distyly to style dimorphism also appears to occur in this tribe. This is the first documented occurrence of such a transition. This secondary style dimorphism is of the relaxed type and demonstrates the labile nature of floral polymorphisms, which are not necessarily a transition towards heterostyly. We discuss the selective forces involved in the evolution, maintainance and loss of style polymorphisms. (C) 2009 Rubel Foundation, ETH Zurich. Published by Elsevier GmbH. All rights reserved.