Avoiding the local trap - Scale and food systems in planning research

被引:626
作者
Born, Branden [1 ]
Purcell, Mark [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Washington, Dept Urban Design & Plannning, Seattle, WA 98195 USA
关键词
food systems; scale;
D O I
10.1177/0739456X06291389
中图分类号
TU98 [区域规划、城乡规划];
学科分类号
0814 ; 082803 ; 0833 ;
摘要
g Current of food-systems research A strong holds that local food systems are preferable to systems at larger scales. Many assume that eating local food is more ecologically sustainable and socially just. We term this the local trap and argue strongly against it. We draw on current scale theory in political and economic geography to argue that local food systems are no more likely to be sustainable or just than systems at other scales. The theory argues that scale is socially produced: scales (and their interrelations) are not independent entities with inherent qualities but strategies pursued by social actors with a particular agenda. It is the content of that agenda, not the scales themselves, that produces outcomes such as sustainability or justice. As planners move increasingly into food-systems research, we argue it is critical to avoid the local trap. The article's theoretical approach to scale offers one way to do so.
引用
收藏
页码:195 / 207
页数:13
相关论文
共 74 条
[11]   The limits to scale? Methodological reflections on scalar structuration [J].
Brenner, N .
PROGRESS IN HUMAN GEOGRAPHY, 2001, 25 (04) :591-614
[12]   Globalisation as reterritorialisation: The re-scaling of urban governance in the European union [J].
Brenner, N .
URBAN STUDIES, 1999, 36 (03) :431-451
[13]   There's nothing inherent about scale: political ecology, the local trap, and the politics of development in the Brazilian Amazon [J].
Brown, JC ;
Purcell, M .
GEOFORUM, 2005, 36 (05) :607-624
[14]   Building a common table - The role for planning in community food systems [J].
Campbell, MC .
JOURNAL OF PLANNING EDUCATION AND RESEARCH, 2004, 23 (04) :341-355
[15]  
CATON CM, 2003, J PLAN EDUC RES, V23, P341
[16]   Potential contributions of planning to community food systems [J].
Clancy, K .
JOURNAL OF PLANNING EDUCATION AND RESEARCH, 2004, 23 (04) :435-438
[17]  
*CTR SUST ENV, 2001, 10 REAS BUY LOC FOOD
[18]   The political construction of scale [J].
Delaney, D ;
Leitner, H .
POLITICAL GEOGRAPHY, 1997, 16 (02) :93-97
[19]   Accessibility versus scale - Examining the tradeoffs in grocery stores [J].
Dunkley, B ;
Helling, A ;
Sawicki, DS .
JOURNAL OF PLANNING EDUCATION AND RESEARCH, 2004, 23 (04) :387-401
[20]   Culture sits in places: reflections on globalism and subaltern strategies of localization [J].
Escobar, A .
POLITICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2001, 20 (02) :139-174