Discriminating between body fat and fluid changes in the obese adult using bioimpedance vector analysis

OBJECTIVE: Conventional body composition methods may produce biased quantification of fat and fat-free mass in obese subjects, due to possible violation of the assumption of constant (73%) tissue hydration. We used an assumption-free, graphical method for interpreting body weight variation in obesity using bioelectrical measurements. DESIGN: 540 obese subjects with body mass index (BMI) > 31 kg/m(2) without apparent edema were compared to 726 healthy subjects with BMI < 31 kg/m(2) and to 50 renal patients with apparent edema. A subgroup of 48 obese subjects were evaluated again after weight loss (8.6 kg, 3 BMI units) following one-month energy restriction (5 MJ/d, 1200 kcal/d). 32 obese uremic patients were evaluated before and after a dialysis session (3.2 kg fluid removed). Direct measurements obtained from standard 50 kHz frequency bioelectrical impedance analyzer were used as impedance vectors in the Resistance-Reactance Graph. RESULTS: 1) Impedance vectors of obese subjects could be discriminated from those of edematous patients with 91% correct allocation; 2) A significant lengthening of vectors was observed after fluid loss of 3 kg in obese subjects; but 3) A body weight loss of about 9 kg after energy restriction was associated with no vector displacement. CONCLUSION: A different impedance vector pattern was associated with body weight loss in obesity due to fluid removal (vector lengthening) versus an energy-restricted diet (no vector displacement).