The hTERT-protein and Ki-67 labelling index in recurrent and non-recurrent meningiomas

Meningiomas are considered as benign neoplasms affecting the coverings of the central nervous system and compromise approximately 20% of all intracranial tumours. However, a number of these tumours recur even after total resection. The aim of this study is to evaluate the prognostic significance for recurrence of the human telomerase catalytic subunit (hTERT) in the cells of meningiomas. The expression of hTERT-protein can be evaluated by immunohistochemical staining using a monoclonal antibody against hTERT (clone 44F42, NCL-L-hTERT). The interdependence between tumour recurrence and cell proliferation in this study is analysed by Ki-67 immunoreactivity (clone MIB-1). Archival material from 29 non-recurrent and 32 recurrent tumours has been evaluated, including specimens from World Health Organization (WHO) stages I (n=73), II(n=2) and III (n=12). Although the tumours were categorized as benign meningiomas following the WHO classification, recurrence in 22 of 50 cases did not correlate with the tumour stage. For hTERT staining, the following results were found for nucleolar and total nuclear staining, respectively: non-recurrent meningiomas, 2.9% (+/-7.7) and 3.0% (+/-8.0); recurrent meningiomas at first resection, 16.8% (+/-19.7) and 31.6% (+/-30.2). Concerning the Ki-67 labelling index (LI): for the group of non-recurrent meningiomas, results were 2.1% (+/-1.7) and for the recurrent group at first resection, 1.7% (+/-2.0). A significant difference was seen for the hTERT staining (P<0.001) between the non-recurrent and recurrent meningiomas, whereas no statistical significance was found for Ki-67. In conclusion hTERT-positive meningiomas had a high incidence for recurrence. Ki-67 was a good marker of cell proliferation status of the tumours, but did not correlate with recurrence; thus, hTERT alone seemed to be a potential predictor for recurrence.