REALIZING EMANCIPATORY PRINCIPLES IN INFORMATION-SYSTEMS DEVELOPMENT - THE CASE FOR ETHICS

被引:138
作者
HIRSCHHEIM, R [1 ]
KLEIN, HK [1 ]
机构
[1] SUNY BINGHAMTO,SCH MANAGEMENT,BINGHAMTON,NY 13902
关键词
NEOHUMANISM; CRITICAL SOCIAL THEORY; EMANCIPATION; PARTICIPATION; INFORMATION SYSTEMS DEVELOPMENT; METHODOLOGY REFORMULATION; SOCIOTECHNICAL DESIGN;
D O I
10.2307/249611
中图分类号
TP [自动化技术、计算机技术];
学科分类号
0812 ;
摘要
Information systems development methodologies have been the subject of much attention over the years. A substantial body of research has focused on the need to develop methodologies that support viewing information systems as social constructs, and information systems development (ISD) as a social process. But if development is a social process, what principles/ideals should inform it? Recent research has called for ''emancipatory'' ideals to be included. This debate can be expanded to explore not only what emancipatory principles might be applied in information systems development, but also how. Existing ISD methodologies only partially embrace emancipatory principles. One of these-ETHICS-seems the most likely candidate to be extended or ''reformulated'' to achieve emancipatory ideals more comprehensively. Organizations using this reformulated version of ETHICS should make some progress advancing emancipation while at the same time confronting limited resources and the presence of power and authority. The approach undertaken here is generic; researchers can similarly apply these reformulation techniques to other methodologies based on other paradigms.
引用
收藏
页码:83 / 109
页数:27
相关论文
共 103 条
[1]  
Albert H., 1968, TRAKTAT KRITISCHE VE
[2]   ON THE IDEA OF EMANCIPATION IN MANAGEMENT AND ORGANIZATION STUDIES [J].
ALVESSON, M ;
WILLMOTT, H .
ACADEMY OF MANAGEMENT REVIEW, 1992, 17 (03) :432-464
[3]  
[Anonymous], 1958, IDEA SOCIAL SCI ITS
[4]   MODELING OFFICES THROUGH DISCOURSE ANALYSIS - THE SAMPO APPROACH [J].
AURAMAKI, E ;
HIRSCHHEIM, R ;
LYYTINEN, K .
COMPUTER JOURNAL, 1992, 35 (04) :342-352
[5]   A SPEECH-ACT-BASED OFFICE MODELING APPROACH [J].
AURAMAKI, E ;
LEHTINEN, E ;
LYYTINEN, K .
ACM TRANSACTIONS ON OFFICE INFORMATION SYSTEMS, 1988, 6 (02) :126-152
[6]  
Avison D. E, 1993, HUMAN ORG SOCIAL DIM
[7]  
Bion W. R., 1959, EXPERIENCES GROUPS
[8]  
Bjerknes G., 1984, 7 SCAND RES SEM SY 2, P204
[9]  
Bodker S., 1987, COMPUTERS DEMOCRACY, P251
[10]  
Bodker S, 1991, DESIGN WORK COOPERAT, P197