IMMUNOTHERAPY WITH HONEYBEE VENOM AND YELLOW JACKET VENOM IS DIFFERENT REGARDING EFFICACY AND SAFETY

被引:231
作者
MULLER, U [1 ]
HELBLING, A [1 ]
BERCHTOLD, E [1 ]
机构
[1] TULANE UNIV, SCH MED, DIV CLIN IMMUNOL & ALLERGY, NEW ORLEANS, LA 70112 USA
关键词
HYMENOPTERA-STING ALLERGY; HONEYBEE VENOM; YELLOW JACKET VENOM; VENOM IMMUNOTHERAPY;
D O I
10.1016/0091-6749(92)90319-W
中图分类号
R392 [医学免疫学];
学科分类号
100102 ;
摘要
Venom immunotherapy (VIT) for Hymenoptera allergy is accepted as safe and effective. However, widely varying success rates and frequencies of side effects are reported. Differences between various Hymenoptera species could account for these diverging results. We therefore analyzed 205 patients with a history of systemic allergic reactions to either honeybee (148 patients) or yellow jacket stings (57 patients) during VIT. All patients had a positive skin test to the respective venom before VIT, were monitored for side effects of VIT, and submitted to a sting challenge while they were receiving VIT. Patients with honeybee-venom allergy had a higher sensitivity in both skin tests (p < 0.05) and RAST (p < 0.001) than patients with yellow jacket-venom allergy. They developed systemic side effects to VIT injections significantly more often (41% versus 25%; p < 0.01) and also reacted more frequently to the sting challenge (23% versus 9%; p < 0.01) than patients with yellow jacket-venom allergy. We conclude that results obtained from studies on the allergy to one Hymenoptera venom cannot be extrapolated to allergies to other Hymenoptera venoms.
引用
收藏
页码:529 / 535
页数:7
相关论文
共 31 条
[21]  
Muller UR, 1990, INSECT STING ALLERGY
[22]   RUSH VENOM IMMUNOTHERAPY - A 3-DAY PROGRAM FOR HYMENOPTERA STING ALLERGY [J].
NATAF, P ;
GUINNEPAIN, MT ;
HERMAN, D .
CLINICAL ALLERGY, 1984, 14 (03) :269-275
[23]   RUSH HYPOSENSITIZATION WITH HYMENOPTERA VENOMS - SIDE REACTIONS AND THERAPEUTIC EFFICACY [J].
PRZYBILLA, B ;
RING, J ;
GRIESSHAMMER, B ;
BRAUNFALCO, O .
DEUTSCHE MEDIZINISCHE WOCHENSCHRIFT, 1987, 112 (11) :416-424
[24]  
RAMIREZ DA, 1981, ANN ALLERGY, V47, P435
[25]  
REISMAN RE, 1983, ALLERGY PRINCIPLES P, P1361
[26]  
ROCKLIN R E, 1982, Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology, V69, P125
[27]   CLINICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF PATIENTS WITH REPEATED SYSTEMIC REACTIONS DURING SPECIFIC IMMUNOTHERAPY WITH HYMENOPTERA VENOMS - A RETROSPECTIVE STUDY [J].
RZANY, B ;
PRZYBILLA, B ;
JARISCH, R ;
ABERER, W ;
DIETSCHI, R ;
WUTHRICH, B ;
BUHLER, B ;
FROSCH, P ;
RAKOSKI, J ;
KIEHN, H ;
KUHN, W ;
URBANEK, R ;
RING, J .
ALLERGY, 1991, 46 (04) :251-254
[28]   DO ALL CHILDREN WITH INSECT ALLERGY NEED VENOM THERAPY [J].
SCHUBERTH, KC ;
GRAFT, DF ;
KAGEYSOBOTKA, A ;
KWITEROVICH, KA ;
SZKLO, M ;
LICHTENSTEIN, LM ;
VALENTINE, MD .
JOURNAL OF ALLERGY AND CLINICAL IMMUNOLOGY, 1983, 71 (01) :140-140
[29]   VENOM IMMUNOTHERAPY IN HYMENOPTERA STING ALLERGY - COMPARISON OF RUSH AND CONVENTIONAL HYPOSENSITIZATION AND OBSERVATIONS DURING LONG-TERM TREATMENT [J].
THURNHEER, U ;
MULLER, U ;
STOLLER, R ;
LANNER, A ;
HOIGNE, R .
ALLERGY, 1983, 38 (07) :465-475
[30]  
WUTHRICH B, 1981, PRAXIS, V70, P934