A COMPARISON OF INTEREST ARBITRATOR DECISION-MAKING IN EXPERIMENTAL AND FIELD SETTINGS

被引：15

作者：

OLSON, CA

DELLOMO, GG

JARLEY, P

机构：

[1] UNIV IOWA,DEPT MANAGEMENT & ORG,IOWA CITY,IA 52242

[2] ST JOSEPHS COLL,HARTFORD,CT

来源：

INDUSTRIAL & LABOR RELATIONS REVIEW | 1992年 / 45卷 / 04期

关键词：

D O I：

10.2307/2524588

中图分类号：

F24 [劳动经济];

学科分类号：

020106 ; 020207 ; 1202 ; 120202 ;

摘要：

Recent studies have investigated arbitrator decision rules in both experimental and field settings. The authors of this paper evaluate the external validity of experimental studies by comparing the decisions made in an experiment with those made in actual cases by the same arbitrators. The results show that when the single-issue decisions made in the experiment are compared with the multi-issue decisions made in many field cases, the arbitrators' decision models in the two settings (as indicated by the weights they attached to various facts of the case and their level of uncertainty about which offer to choose) appear to differ; but when the experimental data are compared to the decisions in the sample of field cases in which the wage was the only issue, the decision models are substantially the same.

引用

页码：711 / 723

页数：13

共 18 条

[1] THE IMPACT OF ARBITRATION - A METHODOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT [J].

ANDERSON, JC .

INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS, 1981, 20 (02) :129-148

[2]

ASHENFELTER O, 1984, AM ECON REV, V74, P111

[3]

BABCOCK L, 1987, UNPUB ROLE INCOMPLET

[4] NORMS OF DISTRIBUTIVE JUSTICE IN INTEREST ARBITRATION [J].

BAZERMAN, MH .

INDUSTRIAL & LABOR RELATIONS REVIEW, 1985, 38 (04) :558-570

[5] ARBITRATOR DECISION-MAKING - WHEN ARE FINAL OFFERS IMPORTANT [J].

BAZERMAN, MH ;

FARBER, HS .

INDUSTRIAL & LABOR RELATIONS REVIEW, 1985, 39 (01) :76-89

[6]

BLOOM DE, 1986, AM ECON REV, V76, P408

[7] EMPIRICAL-MODELS OF ARBITRATOR BEHAVIOR UNDER CONVENTIONAL ARBITRATION [J].

BLOOM, DE .

REVIEW OF ECONOMICS AND STATISTICS, 1986, 68 (04) :578-585

[8]

DELLOMO GG, 1989, ARBITRAT J, V44, P4

[9]

DELLOMO GG, 1987, THESIS U WISCONSIN

[10] INTEREST ARBITRATION, OUTCOMES, AND THE INCENTIVE TO BARGAIN [J].

FARBER, HS ;

KATZ, HC .

INDUSTRIAL & LABOR RELATIONS REVIEW, 1979, 33 (01) :55-63

← 1 2 →