POSTMENOPAUSAL HORMONE-THERAPY AND ATHEROSCLEROTIC DISEASE

Several lines of evidence suggest that estrogen is an important determinant of cardiovascular risk in women. Epidemiologic data document low rates of coronary heart disease (CHD) in premenopausal women, a narrowing of the gender gap in CHD mortality after menopause, and elevated risk of CHD among young women With bilateral oophorectomy not treated with estrogen. Nearly all of the more than 30 observational studies of exogenous estrogen replacement therapy have indicated a reduced risk of CHD among women receiving estrogen therapy. In a meta-analysis comparing estrogen users and nonusers, the estimated reduction of CHD among users was 44%. In angiographic studies, women taking estrogen were less likely to have coronary artery stenosis. Estrogen is known to affect a wide range of physiologic processes that may have an impact on CHD risk. Use of oral estrogen has favorable effects on serum lipid profiles; it increases high-density lipoprotein cholesterol levels by 10% to 15% and decreases low-density lipoprotein cholesterol levels by a similar magnitude. Other proposed mechanisms include inhibition of endothelial hyperplasia, reduced arterial impedance, enhanced production of prostacyclin, increased insulin sensitivity, and inhibition of oxidation of low-density lipoprotein. Nevertheless, the role of hormone replacement therapy in preventing clinical atherosclerotic events in women remains inconclusive because of the absence of randomized trial data. The benefit-to-risk ratio must be reliably assessed, because estrogen has complex actions, including postulated benefits (CHD, osteoporosis, and menopausal symptoms) and postulated risks (endometrial cancer, breast cancer, and gallstones). Furthermore, the addition of a progestin, which is commonly given to protect the endometrium, may attenuate the lipid benefits of estrogen; the benefit-to-risk ratio of such a combined regimen is even less certain. The Women's Health Initiative, a recently launched large-scale randomized trial of estrogen, estrogen-progestin, and placebo, as well as other ongoing randomized trials, will provide invaluable information to aid postmenopausal women in making the complex decision about whether to lake hormone replacement therapy.