INTRAVENOUS CHLORPROMAZINE VS INTRAVENOUS METOCLOPRAMIDE IN ACUTE MIGRAINE HEADACHE

被引:70
作者
CAMERON, JD
LANE, PL
SPEECHLEY, M
机构
[1] ST JOSEPHS HLTH CTR,DEPT EMERGENCY MED,LONDON,ON,CANADA
[2] VICTORIA HOSP,DEPT EMERGENCY MED,LONDON,ON N6A 4G5,CANADA
[3] UNIV WESTERN ONTARIO,DEPT PHYS THERAPY,LONDON,ON,CANADA
[4] UNIV WESTERN ONTARIO,DEPT EPIDEMIOL,LONDON,ON,CANADA
[5] UNIV WESTERN ONTARIO,DEPT BIOSTAT,LONDON,ON,CANADA
关键词
METOCLOPRAMIDE; CHLORPROMAZINE; MIGRAINE HEADACHE;
D O I
10.1111/j.1553-2712.1995.tb03596.x
中图分类号
R4 [临床医学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100602 ;
摘要
Objective: To compare the efficacy of IV chlorpromazine with that of IV metoclopramide in the treatment for acute migraine in the ED. Methods: A prospective randomized double-blind trial was under taken at two university-affiliated urban EDs with a combined annual census of more than 85,000 patients. Included in the study were patients presenting to the ED with a diagnosis of migraine headache. The subjects were randomized to receive 0.1 mg/kg/dose IV of either chlorpromazine (CPZ) or metoclopramide (MC), up to a total of three doses. Results: Ninety-one patients completed the protocol; 44 received MC and 47 received CPZ. The demographics of the two groups were similar. Both drugs provided, for the majority of patients, adequate pain relief as measured on a visual analog scale (VAS) completed every 15 minutes from T = 0 minutes to T = 45 minutes. The average pain relief over 45 minutes (Delta VAS) for CPZ was 4.87 cm, vs 4.34 cm for MC (p = 0.35). There also was no statistically significant difference in blood pressure (BP) changes (Delta BP < 2 mm Hg for both systolic and diastolic BPs, p = 0.47 and 0.33) or numbers of patients reporting adverse effects (AEs) (CPZ: 16 of 35; MC: 13 of 29, p = 0.43). There was no severe AE with either study drug. Conclusions: Metoclopramide and chlorpromazine administered IV acute migraine headache. They are associated with similar minor side-effect profiles.
引用
收藏
页码:597 / 602
页数:6
相关论文
共 21 条
[1]   A COMPARATIVE TRIAL OF 3 AGENTS IN THE TREATMENT OF ACUTE MIGRAINE HEADACHE [J].
BELL, R ;
MONTOYA, D ;
SHUAIB, A ;
LEE, MA .
ANNALS OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 1990, 19 (10) :1079-1082
[2]   TREATMENT OF ACUTE MIGRAINE WITH SUBCUTANEOUS SUMATRIPTAN [J].
CADY, RK ;
WENDT, JK ;
KIRCHNER, JR ;
SARGENT, JD ;
ROTHROCK, JF ;
SKAGGS, H .
JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 1991, 265 (21) :2831-2835
[3]   A CONTROLLED-STUDY OF DIHYDROERGOTAMINE IN THE TREATMENT OF ACUTE MIGRAINE HEADACHE [J].
CALLAHAM, M ;
RASKIN, N .
HEADACHE, 1986, 26 (04) :168-171
[4]   CURRENT CONCEPTS - HEADACHE [J].
CAVINESS, VS ;
OBRIEN, P .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 1980, 302 (08) :446-450
[5]  
Cephalalgia, 1988, CEPHALALGIA, V8, P1
[6]   KETOROLAC VERSUS MEPERIDINE AND HYDROXYZINE IN THE TREATMENT OF ACUTE MIGRAINE HEADACHE - A RANDOMIZED, PROSPECTIVE, DOUBLE-BLIND TRIAL [J].
DUARTE, C ;
DUNAWAY, F ;
TURNER, L ;
ALDAG, J ;
FREDERICK, R .
ANNALS OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 1992, 21 (09) :1116-1121
[7]   THE EFFICACY OF METOCLOPRAMIDE IN THE TREATMENT OF MIGRAINE HEADACHE [J].
ELLIS, GL ;
DELANEY, J ;
DEHART, DA ;
OWENS, A .
ANNALS OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 1993, 22 (02) :191-195
[8]   ORAL SUMATRIPTAN IN ACUTE MIGRAINE [J].
GOADSBY, PJ ;
ZAGAMI, AS ;
DONNAN, GA ;
SYMINGTON, G ;
ANTHONY, M ;
BLADIN, PF ;
LANCE, JW .
LANCET, 1991, 338 (8770) :782-783
[9]   PARENTERAL CHLORPROMAZINE TREATMENT OF MIGRAINE [J].
ISERSON, KV .
ANNALS OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 1983, 12 (12) :756-758
[10]   COMPARATIVE EFFICACY OF CHLORPROMAZINE AND MEPERIDINE WITH DIMENHYDRINATE IN MIGRAINE HEADACHE [J].
LANE, PL ;
MCLELLAN, BA ;
BAGGOLEY, CJ .
ANNALS OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 1989, 18 (04) :360-365