Precision of terrestrial exposure ages and erosion rates estimated from analysis of cosmogenic isotopes produced in situ

被引:42
作者
Gillespie, AR
Bierman, PR
机构
关键词
D O I
10.1029/95JB02911
中图分类号
P3 [地球物理学]; P59 [地球化学];
学科分类号
0708 ; 070902 ;
摘要
The concentration of cosmogenic isotopes produced within mineral grains varies with both the exposure age and erosion rate of the rock surface. In principle therefore, exposure age and erosion rate may be determined by analyzing two cosmogenic isotopes from the same sample, provided the erosion rate is constant. It is also possible to find either age or erosion rate from one isotope if the other parameter can be determined independently. Simple mathematical models predict the precision and accuracy of the exposure ages and erosion rates. The results provide insight into the use of cosmogenic isotopes and a framework to optimize dating experiments and predict tractable geologic questions. The precision and accuracy of the exposure ages and erosion rates depend on the precision of the measured isotope concentrations, the half-lives of the isotopes, and the age and erosion rate of the sampled rock surface. They also vary with the analytic strategy. Exposure age estimates from some isotope pairs approach measurement precision for late-Pleistocene surfaces eroding at <1 cm kyr(-1). Uncertainties in erosion rate for the same surfaces may be better than +/-0.2 cm kyr(-1). For older surfaces the upper limits for both age and erosion rate estimates become infinite. Pairing of isotopes with different half-lives may give misleading results unless the erosion rate is constant because they record different erosion histories. Analyzing a single isotope removes this source of error but is appropriate only if either the age or erosion rate can be well determined independently. If the erosion rate is poorly constrained, ages for some realistic situations may be inaccurate by 50% or more even though their precision may approach the measurement precision. Although it is important to understand the limitations of cosmogenic dating, it is equally important not to lose sight of the potential of this powerful tool for quantitative geomorphologic studies.
引用
收藏
页码:24637 / 24649
页数:13
相关论文
共 24 条
[11]   REVEALING HISTORIES OF EXPOSURE USING INSITU PRODUCED AL-26 AND BE-10 IN LIBYAN DESERT GLASS [J].
KLEIN, J ;
GIEGENGACK, R ;
MIDDLETON, R ;
SHARMA, P ;
UNDERWOOD, JR ;
WEEKS, RA .
RADIOCARBON, 1986, 28 (2A) :547-555
[13]   COSMIC-RAY EXPOSURE DATING WITH INSITU PRODUCED COSMOGENIC HE-3 - RESULTS FROM YOUNG HAWAIIAN LAVA FLOWS [J].
KURZ, MD ;
COLODNER, D ;
TRULL, TW ;
MOORE, RB ;
OBRIEN, K .
EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS, 1990, 97 (1-2) :177-189
[14]   INSITU - PRODUCED COSMOGENIC ISOTOPES IN TERRESTRIAL ROCKS [J].
LAL, D .
ANNUAL REVIEW OF EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCES, 1988, 16 :355-388
[15]   COSMIC-RAY LABELING OF EROSION SURFACES - INSITU NUCLIDE PRODUCTION-RATES AND EROSION MODELS [J].
LAL, D .
EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS, 1991, 104 (2-4) :424-439
[16]   COSMOGENIC CL-36 ACCUMULATION IN UNSTABLE LANDFORMS .1. EFFECTS OF THE THERMAL-NEUTRON DISTRIBUTION [J].
LIU, BL ;
PHILLIPS, FM ;
FABRYKAMARTIN, JT ;
FOWLER, MM ;
STONE, WD .
WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH, 1994, 30 (11) :3115-3125
[17]   COSMIC-RAY PRODUCED BE-10 AND AL-26 IN ANTARCTIC ROCKS - EXPOSURE AND EROSION HISTORY [J].
NISHIIZUMI, K ;
KOHL, CP ;
ARNOLD, JR ;
KLEIN, J ;
FINK, D ;
MIDDLETON, R .
EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS, 1991, 104 (2-4) :440-454
[18]   COSMIC-RAY PRODUCTION-RATES OF BE-10 AND AL-26 IN QUARTZ FROM GLACIALLY POLISHED ROCKS [J].
NISHIIZUMI, K ;
WINTERER, EL ;
KOHL, CP ;
KLEIN, J ;
MIDDLETON, R ;
LAL, D ;
ARNOLD, JR .
JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SOLID EARTH AND PLANETS, 1989, 94 (B12) :17907-17915
[19]   COSMOGENIC BE-10, AL-26, AND HE-3 IN OLIVINE FROM MAUI LAVAS [J].
NISHIIZUMI, K ;
KLEIN, J ;
MIDDLETON, R ;
CRAIG, H .
EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS, 1990, 98 (3-4) :263-266
[20]   ROLE OF IN-SITU COSMOGENIC NUCLIDES BE-10 AND AL-26 IN THE STUDY OF DIVERSE GEOMORPHIC PROCESSES [J].
NISHIZUMI, K ;
KOHL, CP ;
ARNOLD, JR ;
DORN, R ;
KLEIN, J ;
FINK, D ;
MIDDLETON, R ;
LAL, D .
EARTH SURFACE PROCESSES AND LANDFORMS, 1993, 18 (05) :407-425