TABOO TOPICS IN ADDICTION TREATMENT - AN EMPIRICAL REVIEW OF CLINICAL FOLKLORE

被引:45
作者
CHIAUZZI, EJ [1 ]
LILJEGREN, S [1 ]
机构
[1] NE PSYCHIAT ASSOCIATES,NASHUA,NH 03063
关键词
ADDICTIONS; RELAPSE; NICOTINE ADDICTION; EXPECTANCY; MOTIVATION; SPONTANEOUS REMISSION;
D O I
10.1016/0740-5472(93)90079-H
中图分类号
B849 [应用心理学];
学科分类号
040203 ;
摘要
This article reviews 11 taboo topics, that is, research findings that question traditional assumptions and teachings of addiction treatment. These topics include: (1) the lack of empirical support for the Minnesota Model; (2) questions about the necessity of Alcoholics Anonymous for maintaining abstinence; (3) the existence of spontaneous remission; (4) the detrimental aspects of labeling; (5) the value of addicted individuals' self-reports; (6) the lack of empirical support for the addictive personality concept; (7) cue exposure as an underutilized intervention; (8) the interactional nature of motivation; (9) the value of smoking cessation in early recovery; (10) the overuse of the addiction concept; and (11) the lack of empirical support for the disease concept of co-dependency. Misconceptions arise due to the lack of communication between disciplines and the experiential bias of current addiction treatment modalities. Emphasis is placed on the importance of empiricism in order to advance the addiction field beyond faith and supposition.
引用
收藏
页码:303 / 316
页数:14
相关论文
共 152 条
[121]   SPONTANEOUS RECOVERY IN ALCOHOLICS - REVIEW AND ANALYSIS OF AVAILABLE RESEARCH [J].
SMART, RG .
DRUG AND ALCOHOL DEPENDENCE, 1976, 1 (04) :277-285
[122]  
SOBELL L, 1988, BEHAV RES THER, V7, P141
[123]   THE RELIABILITY OF ALCOHOL ABUSERS SELF-REPORTS OF DRINKING AND LIFE EVENTS THAT OCCURRED IN THE DISTANT PAST [J].
SOBELL, LC ;
SOBELL, MB ;
RILEY, DM ;
SCHULLER, R ;
PAVAN, DS ;
CANCILLA, A ;
KLAJNER, F ;
LEO, GI .
JOURNAL OF STUDIES ON ALCOHOL, 1988, 49 (03) :225-232
[124]   MORATORIUM ON MALTZMAN - AN APPEAL TO REASON [J].
SOBELL, MB ;
SOBELL, LC .
JOURNAL OF STUDIES ON ALCOHOL, 1989, 50 (05) :473-480
[125]  
Stockwell T., 1989, HDB ALCOHOLISM TREAT, P222
[126]   ALCOHOLIC DENIAL - A BIOPSYCHOLOGICAL INTERPRETATION [J].
TARTER, RE ;
ALTERMAN, AI ;
EDWARDS, KL .
JOURNAL OF STUDIES ON ALCOHOL, 1984, 45 (03) :214-218
[128]  
TEMPLE MT, 1986, INT J ADDICT, V20, P1585
[129]  
TREBACH A, 1982, HEROIN SOLUTION
[130]  
TRIMPEY J, 1989, RATIONAL RECOVERY AL