COMPARATIVE-STUDY OF ARTIFICIAL NEURAL-NETWORK AND STATISTICAL-MODELS FOR PREDICTING STUDENT GRADE-POINT AVERAGES

被引:89
作者
GORR, WL
NAGIN, D
SZCZYPULA, J
机构
[1] Heinz School of Public Policy and Management, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh
关键词
ARTIFICIAL NEURAL NETWORKS; PREDICTION FORECASTING; COMPARATIVE FORECAST PERFORMANCE;
D O I
10.1016/0169-2070(94)90046-9
中图分类号
F [经济];
学科分类号
02 ;
摘要
This paper compares linear regression; stepwise polynomial regression; and fully-connected, single middle layer artificial neural network models with an index used by an admissions committee for predicting student GPAs in professional school. It also provides methods for implementing, interpreting, and evaluating artificial neural networks, including an optimization of model structure for simple neural networks. While the neural network identifies additional model structure over the regression models, none of the empirical methods was statistically significantly better than the practitioners' index.
引用
收藏
页码:17 / 34
页数:18
相关论文
共 58 条
[31]   ACCURACY OF FORECASTING - EMPIRICAL-INVESTIGATION [J].
MAKRIDAKIS, S ;
HIBON, M .
JOURNAL OF THE ROYAL STATISTICAL SOCIETY SERIES A-STATISTICS IN SOCIETY, 1979, 142 :97-145
[32]   THE ACCURACY OF EXTRAPOLATION (TIME-SERIES) METHODS - RESULTS OF A FORECASTING COMPETITION [J].
MAKRIDAKIS, S ;
ANDERSEN, A ;
CARBONE, R ;
FILDES, R ;
HIBON, M ;
LEWANDOWSKI, R ;
NEWTON, J ;
PARZEN, E ;
WINKLER, R .
JOURNAL OF FORECASTING, 1982, 1 (02) :111-153
[33]  
MCCLELLAND JL, 1986, PARALLEL DISTRIBUTED, V2, P170
[34]  
MELSA P, 1989, TRC8908 TELL RES CTR
[35]   DEMOGRAPHIC-VARIABLES IN MEDICAL-SCHOOL ADMISSION [J].
NOWACEK, G ;
SACHS, L .
ACADEMIC MEDICINE, 1990, 65 (03) :140-144
[36]   PREDICTING THE SECONDARY STRUCTURE OF GLOBULAR-PROTEINS USING NEURAL NETWORK MODELS [J].
Qian, N ;
SEJNOWSKI, TJ .
JOURNAL OF MOLECULAR BIOLOGY, 1988, 202 (04) :865-884
[37]  
RIPLEY BD, 1993, NETWORKS CHAOS STATI
[38]   A STOCHASTIC APPROXIMATION METHOD [J].
ROBBINS, H ;
MONRO, S .
ANNALS OF MATHEMATICAL STATISTICS, 1951, 22 (03) :400-407
[39]  
Rumelhart D.E., 1986, PARALLEL DISTRIBUTED, V1, P318
[40]   LEARNING REPRESENTATIONS BY BACK-PROPAGATING ERRORS [J].
RUMELHART, DE ;
HINTON, GE ;
WILLIAMS, RJ .
NATURE, 1986, 323 (6088) :533-536