EXPERIENCE WITH RADICAL PROSTATECTOMY AND RADIATION-THERAPY FOR LOCALIZED PROSTATE-CANCER AT A VETERANS AFFAIRS MEDICAL-CENTER

We assessed the actuarial survival of 357 patients with localized prostate cancer who were treated with radical prostatectomy or radiation therapy at a Veterans Affairs Medical Center between 1980 and 1991 and who were followed for a median of 59 months. During this period patients with clinical stages A2 and B tumors who had an anticipated life expectancy of 10 years or greater were generally treated with surgery. Patients with stages A2 and B tumors who were not candidates for surgery and those with stage C tumors were generally treated with radiation therapy. There were no significant differences among the cause specific, clinical disease-free and prostate specific antigen disease-free survival curves of patients with stages A2 and B tumors who were treated with radical prostatectomy (138) or radiation therapy (138) but the all cause and metastases-free survival curves favored the surgery group (p <0.000001 and 0.046, respectively). There was no significant difference between the all cause survival curves of the patients with stages A2 and B tumors and of 81 patients with stage C tumors who were treated with radiation therapy. However, the cause specific survival curves favored the patients with stages A2 and B tumors (p = 0.000007). This study demonstrates that there is a high risk of death from co-morbidities in a hospital based population of American veterans with localized prostate cancer who are not candidates for radical prostatectomy.