Quantifying the scanty science of prehospital emergency care

被引:89
作者
Callaham, M
机构
[1] Division of Emergency Medicine, University of California, San Francisco, CA
关键词
D O I
10.1016/S0196-0644(97)70049-0
中图分类号
R4 [临床医学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100602 ;
摘要
Research can produce false-positive results just as can diagnostic tests. Uncontrolled studies have a specificity of only 11%, versus 88% for randomized controlled trials (RCTs), which have been designed to minimize the bias of investigators toward a positive outcome. A search of all the scientific studies in Medline since 1985 revealed 5,842 publications on prehospital EMS, but only 54 were RCTs (and therefore unlikely to produce false-positive results). By way of comparison, during the same time hundreds of RCTs have been conducted on major medical emergency conditions, and RCTs on even minor topics such as urticaria and constipation exceed the scientific database on ail of EMS. Of the 54 EMS RCTs, 4 (7%) reported harm from the new therapy, and 74% reported no effect of the new therapy at all. Only 7 (13%) RCTs showing a positive outcome of the intervention were uncontradicted; of these only 1 examined a major outcome such as survival, and only 1 compared the intervention with a placebo and could therefore evaluate the efficacy of EMS itself. Because there is such a paucity of scientific support for EMS interventions and because monitoring of outcomes and adverse effects is so poor, a serious reexamination of EMS practice is indicated.
引用
收藏
页码:785 / 790
页数:6
相关论文
共 23 条
[1]  
[Anonymous], JAMA, DOI DOI 10.1001/JAMA.1995.03530180050029
[2]   MANUALLY RECORDED TIME [J].
CALLAHAM, M .
ANNALS OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 1994, 24 (05) :990-990
[3]   BIAS IN TREATMENT ASSIGNMENT IN CONTROLLED CLINICAL-TRIALS [J].
CHALMERS, TC ;
CELANO, P ;
SACKS, HS ;
SMITH, H .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 1983, 309 (22) :1358-1361
[4]   HOW STUDY DESIGN AFFECTS OUTCOMES IN COMPARISONS OF THERAPY .1. MEDICAL [J].
COLDITZ, GA ;
MILLER, JN ;
MOSTELLER, F .
STATISTICS IN MEDICINE, 1989, 8 (04) :441-454
[5]   DOES ANYBODY REALLY KNOW WHAT TIME IT IS - DOES ANYBODY REALLY CARE [J].
CORDELL, WH ;
OLINGER, ML ;
KOZAK, PA ;
NYHUIS, AW .
ANNALS OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 1994, 23 (05) :1032-1036
[6]   THE ESOPHAGEAL DETECTOR DEVICE - AN ASSESSMENT OF ACCURACY AND EASE OF USE BY PARAMEDICS [J].
DONAHUE, PL .
ANAESTHESIA, 1994, 49 (10) :863-865
[7]   Checking the carotid pulse check: Diagnostic accuracy of first responders in patients with and without a pulse [J].
Eberle, B ;
Dick, WF ;
Schneider, T ;
Wisser, G ;
Doetsch, S ;
Tzanova, I .
RESUSCITATION, 1996, 33 (02) :107-116
[8]  
GAUSCHE M, 1985, PROSPECTIVE RANDOMIZ
[9]   Comparison of a vacuum splint device to a rigid backboard for spinal immobilization [J].
Johnson, DR ;
Hauswald, M ;
Stockhoff, C .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 1996, 14 (04) :369-372
[10]   IMPACT OF 1ST-RESPONDER DEFIBRILLATION IN AN URBAN EMERGENCY MEDICAL-SERVICES SYSTEM [J].
KELLERMANN, AL ;
HACKMAN, BB ;
SOMES, G ;
KRETH, TK ;
NAIL, L ;
DOBYNS, P .
JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 1993, 270 (14) :1708-1713