Spondylodesis in the treatment of segmental instability of the lumbar spine with special reference to clinically verified instability

We analysed the outcome of 42 consecutive patients suffering from low back pain and segmental instability of the lumbar spine who underwent spondylodesis with transpedicular fixation. There were 29 (69%) females and 13 (31%) males with a mean age of 47 +/- 9 years (range 23 to 66 years). The presence of clinically verified instability was a basic requirement for operative treatment, with at least one clinical sign of instability positive in all patients. Radiological signs of instability were detected in only 74 % of the patients. After a postoperative follow-up of one year, lumbar fusion was found in 38 (90%) patients. The fusion was classified as complete in 18 (43%) and as partial in 20 (47%) patients. No fusion there was detected in 4 (10%) patients. Low back pain was completely abolished in 19 (45%) and markedly diminished in 15 (36%) patients. In 7 (17%) patients, low back pain had remained unchanged and become worse in 1 (2%) patient. Clinical signs and symptoms of instability were still detected in 10 (24%) patients. As compared to the pre-operative situation, the decrease in clinical instability was statistically significant (p = 0.02). Moreover, a significant correlation was observed between the persistence of clinically verified instability and a poor postoperative outcome in daily activities. Of all patients, 17 (40%) returned to work during the period of followup. Based on the good outcome of our patients, the results of this study show that clinical signs and symptoms of instability can be successfully used as selection criteria for lumbar spondylodesis.