Cytosine deaminase versus thymidine kinase:: a comparison of the antitumor activity

The efficacy of single and combination suicide gene therapy was evaluated using a Herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase/ganciclovir system and Escherichia coli cytosine deaminase/5-fluorocytosine system on the rat prostate tumor cell line R3327 AT-1. The wild-type R3327 AT-1 cell line was transfected with a bifunctional fusion gene CDglyTK, which had the advantage that the resulting R3327 AT-1/CDglyTK cell line has the same amount of cytosine deaminase and thymidine kinase molecules. The percentage of viable R3327 AT-1/CDglyTK cells after 96 h incubation with 0.1 mug/ml ganciclovir or 10 mug/ml 5-fluorocytosine were 85% and 52% of controls, respectively. The cell viability when both suicide genes systems were activated was 43%. For in vivo analysis, Copenhagen rats were injected subcutaneously with R3327 AT-1 or R3327 AT-1/CDglyTK cells and treated with 30 mg/kg ganciclovir, 500 mg/kg 5-fluorocytosine, or both prodrugs together. A survival of 83% with the thymidine kinase/ganciclovir and 57% with the CD/5-FC could be observed. Only co-administration of thymidine kinase- and cytosine deaminase-specific prodrugs resulted in a 100% recurrence-free survival of the Copenhagen rats with a Dunning R3327 AT-1/CDglyTK prostate tumor and showed an additive cytotoxic effect. Calculation of the degree of activation and the potential of activation can be used to predict the success of a suicide gene therapy. In our case, the cytosine deaminase/5-fluorocytosine system had a low degree of activation (value 40), which is also found in the low response to 5- fluorocytosine in vivo (57% tumor free).