Mechanistic investigations on the reaction between 1,2-dioxines and bulky stabilized phosphorus ylides: An efficient route to closely related cyclopropane stereoisomers

The bulky stabilized ylides (2a-d) react with a range of 1,2-dioxines (1a-d) to afford the diversely functionalized cyclopropanes 7 in excellent yield and diastereomeric excess. This is in direct contrast to the situation when nonbulky ester ylides are utilized which results in a completely different cyclopropyl series. Through a combination of isolation, spectroscopic, temperature, and deuterium and additive effects studies, the mechanism of cyclopropane formation from this second pathway can be proposed. Importantly, enolate quenching of the intermediate 1-2 gimel (5)-oxaphospholanes 4 prior to collapse results in an equilibrium mixture of intermediates 10 and 11 which have been fully characterized, and their formation is primarily a result of the steric bulk of the stabilized ester ylide. These intermediates (10/11) then collapse further and result in formation of the observed closely related cyclopropyl stereoisomers 7 and 8. Moreover, the addition of LiBr to these reactions allows for the control of which of the two possible cyclopropanation pathways will be dominant. Finally, optimal protocols that demonstrate the potential of this new cyclopropanation methodology for the ready construction of closely related cyclopropyl stereoisomers are presented.