The SCARE 2020 Guideline: Updating Consensus Surgical CAse REport (SCARE) Guidelines

被引：2278

作者：

Agha, Riaz A. ^{[1
]}

Franchi, Thomas ^{[2
]}

Sohrabi, Catrin ^{[3
]}

Mathew, Ginimol ^{[4
]}

Kerwan, Ahmed ^{[5
]}

Thoma, Achilles ^{[6
]}

Beamish, Andrew J. ^{[7
]}

Noureldin, Ashraf ^{[8
]}

Rao, Ashwini ^{[9
]}

Vasudevan, Baskaran ^{[10
]}

Challacombe, Ben ^{[11
]}

Perakath, Benjamin ^{[12
]}

Kirshtein, Boris ^{[13
]}

Ekser, Burcin ^{[14
]}

Pramesh, C. S. ^{[15
]}

Laskin, Daniel M. ^{[16
,17
]}

Machado-Aranda, David ^{[18
]}

Miguel, Diana ^{[19
]}

Pagano, Duilio ^{[20
]}

Millham, Frederick H. ^{[21
]}

Roy, Gaurav ^{[22
]}

Kadioglu, Huseyin ^{[23
]}

Nixon, Iain J. ^{[24
]}

Mukhejree, Indraneil ^{[25
]}

McCaul, James A. ^{[26
]}

Ngu, James Chi-Yong ^{[27
]}

Albrecht, Joerg ^{[28
]}

Gomez Rivas, Juan ^{[29
]}

Raveendran, Kandiah ^{[30
]}

Derbyshire, Laura ^{[31
]}

Ather, M. Hammad ^{[32
]}

Thorat, Mangesh A. ^{[33
]}

Valmasoni, Michele ^{[34
]}

Bashashati, Mohammad ^{[35
]}

Chalkoo, Mushtaq ^{[36
]}

Teo, Nan Zun ^{[27
]}

Raison, Nicholas ^{[37
]}

Muensterer, Oliver J. ^{[38
]}

Bradley, Patrick James ^{[39
]}

Goel, Prabudh ^{[40
]}

Pai, Prathamesh S. ^{[41
]}

Afifi, Raafat Yahia ^{[42
]}

Rosin, Richard David ^{[43
]}

Coppola, Roberto ^{[44
]}

Klappenbach, Roberto ^{[45
]}

Wynn, Rolf ^{[46
]}

De Wilde, Rudy Leon ^{[47
]}

Surani, Salim ^{[48
]}

Giordano, Salvatore ^{[49
]}

Massarut, Samuele ^{[50
]}

机构：

[1] Barts Hlth NHS Trust, Dept Plast Surg, London, England

[2] Univ Sheffield, Med Sch, Sheffield, S Yorkshire, England

[3] Queen Mary Univ London, Barts & London Sch Med & Dent, London, England

[4] York Teaching Hosp NHS Fdn Trust, York, N Yorkshire, England

[5] Lister Hosp, Dept Surg, East & North Hertfordshire NHS Trust, Stevenage, Herts, England

[6] McMaster Univ, Hamilton, ON, Canada

[7] Swansea Univ, Med Sch, Swansea, W Glam, Wales

[8] Almana Hosp Khobar, Khobar, Saudi Arabia

[9] Manipal Acad Higher Educ, MCODS Mangalore, Manipal, India

[10] MIOT Hosp, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India

[11] Guys & St Thomas NHS Fdn Trust, London, England

[12] Dr Grays Hosp, Elgin, Scotland

[13] Rabin MC, Petah Tiqwa, Israel

[14] Indiana Univ Sch Med, Indianapolis, IN 46202 USA

[15] Tata Mem Hosp, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India

[16] Virginia Commonwealth Univ, Sch Dent, Richmond, VA USA

[17] Virginia Commonwealth Univ, Sch Med, Richmond, VA USA

[18] Univ Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA

[19] Cuf Descobertas Hosp, Lisbon, Portugal

[20] IRCCS ISMETT UPMC, Palermo, Italy

[21] Harvard Univ, Cambridge, MA 02138 USA

[22] Sir Ganga Ram Hosp, New Delhi, India

[23] BHT Clin, Istanbul, Turkey

[24] Univ Edinburgh, NHS Lothian, Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland

[25] Staten Isl Univ Hosp, Zucker Sch Med, New York, NY USA

[26] Queen Elizabeth Univ Hosp, Glasgow, Lanark, Scotland

[27] Changi Gen Hosp, Singapore, Singapore

[28] Rush Med Coll, Cook Cty Hlth, Chicago, IL 60612 USA

[29] La Paz Univ Hosp, La Paz, Spain

[30] Fatimah Hosp, Ipoh, Malaysia

[31] Manchester Univ NHS Fdn Trust, Manchester, Lancs, England

[32] Aga Khan Univ, Karachi, Pakistan

[33] Queen Mary Univ London, Kings Coll London, Guys Hosp, London, England

[34] Padova Univ Hosp, Padua, Italy

[35] Texas Tech Univ, Hlth Sci Ctr, Lubbock, TX 79430 USA

[36] Govt Med Coll Srinagar, Srinagar, India

[37] Kings Coll London, London, England

[38] Univ Munich, Dr von Hauner Childrens Hosp, Munich, Germany

[39] Nottingham Univ Hosp, Nottingham, England

[40] All India Inst Med Sci, New Delhi, India

[41] Tata Mem Hosp, Homi Bhabha Natl Inst, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India

[42] Cairo Univ, Cairo, Egypt

[43] Univ West Indies, Wanstead, Barbados

[44] Campus Biomedico Univ, Sch Med, Rome, Italy

[45] Hosp Simplemente Evita, Gonzalez Catan, Argentina

[46] UiT Arctic Univ Norway, Univ Hosp North Norway, Tromso, Norway

[47] Carl von Ossietzky Univ Oldenburg, Oldenburg, Germany

[48] Texas A&M Univ, College Stn, TX USA

[49] Turku Univ Hosp, Turku, Finland

[50] CRO Aviano Natl Canc Inst IRCCS, Aviano, Italy

来源：

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SURGERY | 2020年 / 84卷

关键词：

SCARE; Guideline; Surgery; Case report;

D O I：

10.1016/j.ijsu.2020.10.034

中图分类号：

R61 [外科手术学];

学科分类号：

100210 [外科学];

摘要：

Introduction: The SCARE Guidelines were first published in 2016 and were last updated in 2018. They provide a structure for reporting surgical case reports and are used and endorsed by authors, journal editors and reviewers, in order to increase robustness and transparency in reporting surgical cases. They must be kept up to date in order to drive forwards reporting quality. As such, we have updated these guidelines via a DELPHI consensus exercise. Methods: The updated guidelines were produced via a DELPHI consensus exercise. Members were invited from the previous DELPHI group, as well as editorial board members and peer reviewers of the International Journal of Surgery Case Reports. The expert group completed an online survey to indicate their agreement with proposed changes to the checklist items. Results: A total of 54 surgical experts agreed to participate and 53 (98%) completed the survey. The responses and suggested modifications were incorporated into the new 2020 guideline. There was a high degree of agreement amongst the SCARE Group, with all modified SCARE items receiving over 70% scores 7-9. Conclusion: A DELPHI consensus exercise was completed and an updated and improved SCARE Checklist is now presented.

引用

页码：226 / 230

页数：5

共 5 条

[1]

Impact of the SCARE guideline on the reporting of surgical case reports: A before and after study [J].

Agha, R. A. ;

Farwana, R. ;

Borrelli, M. R. ;

Tickunas, T. ;

Kusu-Orkar, T. ;

Millip, M. C. ;

Thavayogan, R. ;

Garner, J. ;

Orgill, D. P. .

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 2017, 45 :144-148

[2]

The SCARE 2018 statement: Updating consensus Surgical CAse REport (SCARE) guidelines [J].

Agha, Riaz A. ;

Borrelli, Mimi R. ;

Farwana, Reem ;

Koshy, Kiron ;

Fowler, Alexander J. ;

Orgill, Dennis P. ;

Zhu, Hongyi ;

Alsawadi, Abdulrahman ;

Noureldin, Ashraf ;

Rao, Ashwini ;

Enam, Ather ;

Thoma, Achilleas ;

Bashashati, Mohammad ;

Vasudevan, Baskaran ;

Beamish, Andrew ;

Challacombe, Ben ;

De Wilde, Rudy Leon ;

Machado-Aranda, David ;

Laskin, Daniel ;

Muzumdar, Dattatraya ;

D'cruz, Anil ;

Manning, Todd ;

Healy, Donagh ;

Pagano, Duilio ;

Goel, Prabudh ;

Ranganathan, Priya ;

Pai, Prathamesh S. ;

Raja, Shahzad ;

Athe, M. Hammad ;

Kadioazlu, Huseyin ;

Nixon, Iain ;

Mukherjee, Indraneil ;

Gomez Riva, Juan ;

Raveendran, Kandiah ;

Derbyshire, Laura ;

Valmasoni, Michele ;

Chalkoo, Mushtaq ;

Raison, Nicholas ;

Muensterer, Oliver ;

Bradley, Patrick ;

Roberto, Coppola ;

Afifi, Raafat ;

Rosin, David ;

Klappenbach, Roberto ;

Wynn, Rolf ;

Giordano, Salvatore ;

Basu, Somprakas ;

Surani, Salim ;

Suman, Paritosh ;

Thorat, Mangesh .

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 2018, 60 :132-136

[3]

Support for reporting guidelines in surgical journals needs improvement: A systematic review [J].

Agha, Riaz A. ;

Barai, Ishani ;

Rajmohan, Shivanchan ;

Lee, Seon ;

Anwar, Mohammed O. ;

Fowler, Alexander J. ;

Orgill, Dennis P. ;

Altman, Douglas G. .

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 2017, 45 :14-17

[4]

The SCARE Statement: Consensus-based surgical case report guidelines [J].

Agha, Riaz A. ;

Fowler, Alexander J. ;

Saeta, Alexandra ;

Barai, Ishani ;

Rajmohan, Shivanchan ;

Orgill, Dennis P. ;

Afifi, Raafat ;

Al-Ahmadi, Raha ;

Albrecht, Joerg ;

Alsawadi, Abdulrahman ;

Aronson, Jeffrey ;

Ather, M. Hammad ;

Bashashati, Mohammad ;

Basu, Somprakas ;

Bradley, Patrick ;

Chalkoo, Mushtaq ;

Challacombe, Ben ;

Cross, Trent ;

Derbyshire, Laura ;

Farooq, Naheed ;

Hoffman, Jerome ;

Kadioglu, Huseyin ;

Kasivisvanathan, Veeru ;

Kirshtein, Boris ;

Klappenbach, Roberto ;

Laskin, Daniel ;

Miguel, Diana ;

Milburn, James ;

Mousavi, Seyed Reza ;

Muensterer, Oliver ;

Ngu, James ;

Nixon, Iain ;

Noureldin, Ashraf ;

Perakath, Benjamin ;

Raison, Nicholas ;

Raveendran, Kandiah ;

Sullivan, Timothy ;

Thoma, Achilleas ;

Thorat, Mangesh ;

Valmasoni, Michele ;

Massarut, Samuele ;

D'cruz, Anil ;

Vasudevan, Baskaran ;

Giordano, Salvatore ;

Roy, Gaurav ;

Healy, Donagh ;

Machado-Aranda, David ;

Carroll, Bryan ;

Rosin, David .

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 2016, 34 :180-186

[5]

DELPHI METHOD - SUBSTANCE, CONTEXT - CRITIQUE AN AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY [J].

PILL, J .

SOCIO-ECONOMIC PLANNING SCIENCES, 1971, 5 (01) :57-71

← 1 →