Nucleosides with a twist. Can fixed forms of sugar ring pucker influence biological activity in nucleosides and oligonucleotides?

The sugar moiety of nucleosides in solution is known to exist in a rapid dynamic equilibrium between extreme Northern and Southern conformations as defined in the pseudorotational cycle. In the present work, we describe how the bicyclo[3.1.0]hexane template fixes the ring pucker of 2'-deoxy-methanocarba-nucleosides 1-5 and 12 to values corresponding to either one of these two extreme conformations that are typical of nucleosides. The syntheses of the fixed Northern conformers 1-5 were performed by Mitsunobu coupling of the heterocyclic bases with the chiral carbocyclic alcohol 6 [(1R,2S,4R,5S)-1-[(benzyloxy)methyl]-2-(tert-butyloxy)4-hydroxybicyclo[3.1.0]hexane], while the synthesis of the Southern conformer, (S)-methanocarba-T (12), was reported earlier. Carbocyclic thymidine (carba-T, 13) was used as a reference, flexible carbocyclic nucleoside. Antiviral evaluation of these compounds revealed a very potent antiherpetic activity associated with the Northern thymidine analogue 2, which was more powerful than the reference standard acyclovir against both HSV-1 and HSV-2. (N)-Methanocarba-T (2) was further evaluated as a component of a short oligodeoxynucleotide (ODN) phosphorothioate (5'-CTTCATTTTTTCTTC-3') where all thymidines were replaced by 2. The expected thermodynamic stability resulting from the preorganization of the pseudosugar rings into a Northern conformation, typical of A-DNA, was evident by the increase in T-m of the corresponding DNA/RNA heteroduplex. However, the rigid A-tract ODN caused loss of RNase H recruitment. A detailed conformational analysis of (N)-methanocarba-T (2) and (S)-methanocarba-T (12), as representative examples of conformationally rigid pseudorotational antipodes, revealed that in addition to their different forms of ring pucker, (S)-methanocarba-T appears to be a rather stiff molecule with fewer low-energy conformational states available compared to (N)-methanocarba-T. The syn/anti-energy barrier for these nucleoside analogues is 5-6 kcal/mol higher than for common nucleosides.